Russia Defence Forum

Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

Military Forum for Russian and Global Defence Issues


+64
Karl Haushofer
par far
calripson
bandit6
Mir
limb
Azi
Isos
LMFS
Big_Gazza
TMA1
ALAMO
nomadski
lyle6
Erk
kvs
Mig-31BM2 Super Irbis-E
mnztr
caveat emptor
dionis
0nillie0
mr_hd
rfan
Arsenic
zorobabel
ludovicense
Dr.Snufflebug
billybatts91
Rodion_Romanovic
OminousSpudd
Ispan
Singular_Transform
psg
Werewolf
crod
Firebird
Scorpius
PapaDragon
PhSt
flamming_python
Odin of Ossetia
Regular
JohninMK
ATLASCUB
lancelot
walle83
Airbornewolf
Stealthflanker
ucmvulcan
VARGR198
ArgentinaGuard
SeigSoloyvov
Podlodka77
Arrow
Belisarius
andalusia
Broski
Arkanghelsk
sepheronx
GarryB
thegopnik
franco
Backman
Hole
68 posters

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    caveat emptor
    caveat emptor


    Posts : 1778
    Points : 1778
    Join date : 2022-02-02
    Location : Murrica

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  caveat emptor Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:12 pm

    ALAMO wrote:
    Quite easy bro.
    It seems that there was a few hundred of Russkie covering forces there, and that's it.
    Is it a fuckup or a trap, we will see.
    As far as we know, there are close to zero Russkie lost, thousands of Ukrs, and we do worry about the civilians left there.
    We agree on that. Ukrainians by luck or planning found a weak spot in defense and whole thing collapsed. I've seen numbers of 900 soldiers guarding Balakleya sector. How the **** that happened and why they didn't call up reinforcements sooner?
    My understanding of Russian defence was that due to not enough manpower, they behave like German army around Tannenberg and Masurian lakes in WW1. As soon as you see a potential for breach you call in cavalry. Not to mention that Balakleya was guarding Izyum, that was really important for whole Donbass offensive.

    BliTTzZ likes this post

    caveat emptor
    caveat emptor


    Posts : 1778
    Points : 1778
    Join date : 2022-02-02
    Location : Murrica

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  caveat emptor Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:16 pm

    Backman wrote:
    They took it all back after Karkiv doom 1.0. That was all a big psyop with retards like Zoka dooming the whole way.

    How is Ukraine going to have the material to actually hold any of this the 3rd time ?
    They never took everything back, but that is beside the point. Territory lost then dwarfs what has been lost now. Now they basically lost a foothold in Izyum that was won by blood in March/April. And many others  territories with pro-Russian populace.
    avatar
    ALAMO


    Posts : 6842
    Points : 6934
    Join date : 2014-11-26

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  ALAMO Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:18 pm

    You can't call "a collapse" something that brought close to zero casualties and really irrelevant strategic importance.
    When Donbas will be done, they will just move north.
    The operation is still going, so I would withstand from any serious&final judgments.

    sepheronx, GarryB, flamming_python, Big_Gazza, kvs, Hole, Backman and like this post

    Backman
    Backman


    Posts : 2606
    Points : 2618
    Join date : 2020-11-11

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  Backman Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:19 pm

    flamming_python wrote:The infection is at such an advanced stage that victims are competing with each other over who generates more panic highs

    Yeah. It's truly sickening. Just giving away the propaganda win. An emotionally charged crowd is usually always wrong.

    Russians just don't have the viceral hate for the enemy like the Anglo axis population does. So they just can't carry the propaganda the way the west does.

    GarryB, Werewolf, Big_Gazza, kvs, Broski, Belisarius and Podlodka77 like this post

    caveat emptor
    caveat emptor


    Posts : 1778
    Points : 1778
    Join date : 2022-02-02
    Location : Murrica

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  caveat emptor Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:23 pm

    ALAMO wrote:You can't call "a collapse" something that brought close to zero casualties and really irrelevant strategic importance.
    When Donbas will be done, they will just move north.
    The operation is still going, so I would withstand from any serious&final judgments.
    I don't agree. Izyum raion was pivotal for Donbass offensive. Also very important logistically. It is literally opening  Kramatorsk-Slavyansk agglomeration and provides route for Lozovoe and Pavlograd after it.
    Backman
    Backman


    Posts : 2606
    Points : 2618
    Join date : 2020-11-11

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  Backman Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:26 pm

    caveat emptor wrote:
    Backman wrote:
    They took it all back after Karkiv doom 1.0. That was all a big psyop with retards like Zoka dooming the whole way.

    How is Ukraine going to have the material to actually hold any of this the 3rd time ?
    They never took everything back, but that is beside the point. Territory lost then dwarfs what has been lost now. Now they basically lost a foothold in Izyum that was won by blood in March/April. And many others  territories with pro-Russian populace.

    Well i heard they took everything back and more. But maybe your map autist has different view than mine.

    This is the problem with map autism. You literally look at this as a football game. You think Ukraine "taking back" territory is no different than Russia taking it. Russia beat back static defenses. Ukraine pushed on an open door.


    GarryB, Big_Gazza, kvs, Hole, Broski, Belisarius and Podlodka77 like this post

    caveat emptor
    caveat emptor


    Posts : 1778
    Points : 1778
    Join date : 2022-02-02
    Location : Murrica

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  caveat emptor Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:32 pm

    Mig-31BM2 Super Irbis-E wrote:The losses of territory are not to be discussed. How long was used to take these areas? What did it cost about blood?
    Most of the territory in Kharkov oblast they took in the beginning with very little fighting. 
    Izyum and its vicinity were taken after heavy fights that took about 2 months

    thegopnik likes this post

    Backman dislikes this post

    thegopnik
    thegopnik


    Posts : 1739
    Points : 1741
    Join date : 2017-09-20

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  thegopnik Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:34 pm

    Its not even going to matter anymore if Russia somehow recaptures everything the Ukrainians took. There is going to be alot of media news everywhere about how the brave hohols fought off the super power invaders and made such a huge push possible. I ABSOLUTELY guarantee you there is going to be lots and lots of foreign mercernaries coming from ass-hurt post soviet block countries to get involved in this war more than ever now, especially with the ramstein meeting for hohols to get supplied more with weapins. post-soviet block countries are no slouches when it comes to warfare and we will possibly have ourselves a bigger slav extermination than we did in WW2 with what UPA did to poles, what nazis did to soviets and what ustase did to serbs.

    There are two ways that I can think of that must be done to correct this **** up. Step 1 recapture everything the ukrainians gained in ther counter attack. 2. immediately grab a ukrainian city that wasnt claimed before.
    caveat emptor
    caveat emptor


    Posts : 1778
    Points : 1778
    Join date : 2022-02-02
    Location : Murrica

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  caveat emptor Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:35 pm

    Backman wrote:Well i heard they took everything back and more. But maybe your map autist has different view than mine.

    This is the problem with map autism. You literally look at this as a football game. You think Ukraine "taking back" territory is no different than Russia taking it. Russia beat back static defenses. Ukraine pushed on an open door.
    Kupyansk and territory north of it between Oskol and Severskiy Donets rivers were taken in the beginning and with little fight.
    Backman
    Backman


    Posts : 2606
    Points : 2618
    Join date : 2020-11-11

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  Backman Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:39 pm

    They could mobilize troops and make it 3:1 if needed. This under 1:1 thing was working but if not , then go for 3:1.

    The doomer morons talk like this isn't even an option

    Russia could probably beat back this stragglers offensive but just for propaganda purposes , they really should mobilize 100-200k troops. Knowing this govt , they won't. But they should.


    Last edited by Backman on Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:43 pm; edited 1 time in total

    kvs likes this post

    avatar
    ALAMO


    Posts : 6842
    Points : 6934
    Join date : 2014-11-26

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  ALAMO Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:42 pm

    caveat emptor wrote:
    I don't agree. Izyum raion was pivotal for Donbass offensive. Also very important logistically. It is literally opening  Kramatorsk-Slavyansk agglomeration and provides route for Lozovoe and Pavlograd after it.

    Have you bothered to take a look at a map, accidentally? scratch
    You have much better road access from the Gorlovka and Doneck directions.
    That is why they focus on Artemovsk now, as it blocks the route.
    The railroad in Izum is heading to Slovyansk and Charkov.
    Gorlovka-Konstantinovka-Slavyansk-Krematorsk-Izum-Charkov. We talk this line.
    They connect in in Maiorsk with a line that heads Bachmut and Rubezhnoye.

    GarryB, Big_Gazza, kvs, Hole and Belisarius like this post

    TMA1
    TMA1


    Posts : 1135
    Points : 1133
    Join date : 2020-11-30

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  TMA1 Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:43 pm

    caveat emptor wrote:
    ALAMO wrote:You can't call "a collapse" something that brought close to zero casualties and really irrelevant strategic importance.
    When Donbas will be done, they will just move north.
    The operation is still going, so I would withstand from any serious&final judgments.
    I don't agree. Izyum raion was pivotal for Donbass offensive. Also very important logistically. It is literally opening  Kramatorsk-Slavyansk agglomeration and provides route for Lozovoe and Pavlograd after it.

    But Russia is not even fighting this conflict as it has not even declared war and is instead supporting the Russian allied Ukrainians with intelligence and artillery and air support and a few volunteer groups. This shit is much more complicated than propaganda wins or losses. Frankly I have already heard from reddit tier retards losses of hundreds of Russian tanks and Russian generals fleeing on bicycles.

    This is the level of horseshit I am seeing from the other side. Apparently mods are okay with letting those retards post here. Nah we dont even know how bad it all is or how blown out of proportion it all is and I will certainly not trust outside shills and anti russian posters to give me the scoop on what is happening.

    Big_Gazza, kvs, BliTTzZ, Backman, Broski, Belisarius and Podlodka77 like this post

    avatar
    ALAMO


    Posts : 6842
    Points : 6934
    Join date : 2014-11-26

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  ALAMO Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:46 pm

    We will go nowhere by calling everyone who has a different opinion a retard bro.
    As long as we talk about people, who have their own opinions, is just perfectly fine.

    BliTTzZ likes this post

    Backman
    Backman


    Posts : 2606
    Points : 2618
    Join date : 2020-11-11

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  Backman Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:46 pm

    Russian Head telegram

    All this doomposting and spreading panic -is it a concerted effort of the enemy? Sure seems like it. Ok, Russia retreated. So what? As long as their losses are minimal compared to Ukraine's. Then the counter attack will happen. The offensive will exhaust, and the nationalist grouping will be destroyed. So you suddenly think the Russian Armed Forces became incompetent after 6 months of success? Calm the **** down ...

    GarryB, Firebird, flamming_python, Big_Gazza, kvs, Rodion_Romanovic, AMK and like this post

    kvs
    kvs


    Posts : 15185
    Points : 15322
    Join date : 2014-09-11
    Location : Turdope's Kanada

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  kvs Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:52 pm

    ALAMO wrote:We will go nowhere by calling everyone who has a different opinion a retard bro.
    As long as we talk about people, who have their own opinions, is just perfectly fine.

    Retard is as retard does. All the Ukr victory spammers and concern trolls are defined by their actions.

    GarryB, Firebird, Werewolf, Big_Gazza, Hole, Backman, TMA1 and like this post

    caveat emptor
    caveat emptor


    Posts : 1778
    Points : 1778
    Join date : 2022-02-02
    Location : Murrica

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  caveat emptor Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:55 pm

    ALAMO wrote:
    Have you bothered to take a look at a map, accidentally? scratch
    You have much better road access from the Gorlovka and Doneck directions.
    That is why they focus on Artemovsk now, as it blocks the route.
    The railroad in Izum is heading to Slovyansk and Charkov.
    Gorlovka-Konstantinovka-Slavyansk-Krematorsk-Izum-Charkov. We talk this line.
    They connect in in Maiorsk with a line that heads Bachmut and Rubezhnoye.
    Whole premise of Donbass offensive was, when Artemovsk- Seversk line is done, to launch a two pronged attack from east and north and spread Ukrainian units. Also cut railway line between Barvenkovo and Kramatorsk or completely take Barvenkovo.
    avatar
    ALAMO


    Posts : 6842
    Points : 6934
    Join date : 2014-11-26

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  ALAMO Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:55 pm

    True.
    But some of them are driven by either fear or wrongly understanding patriotism.
    It is still an opinion of fellow guy.
    ATLASCUB
    ATLASCUB


    Posts : 1154
    Points : 1158
    Join date : 2017-02-13

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  ATLASCUB Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:57 pm

    As long as we get to know what Mercousis is thinking... lol1

    Retard is what retard does indeed.
    SeigSoloyvov
    SeigSoloyvov


    Posts : 3721
    Points : 3701
    Join date : 2016-04-08

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  SeigSoloyvov Sat Sep 10, 2022 8:59 pm

    Backman wrote:Russian Head telegram

    All this doomposting and spreading panic -is it a concerted effort of the enemy? Sure seems like it. Ok, Russia retreated. So what? As long as their losses are minimal compared to Ukraine's. Then the counter attack will happen. The offensive will exhaust, and the nationalist grouping will be destroyed. So you suddenly think the Russian Armed Forces became incompetent after 6 months of success? Calm the **** down ...

    This logic is funny, it doesn't matter how much success you have, all it takes is a few major fucks up to make major costs occur.

    The fanboys are down playing the loss of Izyum (which was strategic and tactical import to the entire Donbas operation), its sad honestly rather than accept a massive failure was made one that could have been AVOIDED by deploying the correct number of troops and treating this like a REAL dam war.

    Believe I said time and time again, Russia didn't have enough manpower in the field and this OCCURED exactly because of that.

    That's the difference tho between people who actually fought battles and armchair experts, we know better than the ladder thinks they do.

    Oh well spin it all you wish, make up all the excuses you wish doesn't change the fact the Russian brass failed here and miserably.

    Yes its war and mistake happen but this is one mistake that shouldn't have happened with modern day tech

    Arsenic likes this post

    Arsenic
    Arsenic


    Posts : 73
    Points : 75
    Join date : 2022-02-27

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  Arsenic Sat Sep 10, 2022 9:02 pm

    We will stay calm and wait for the Russian counterattack...

    On the other hand it is not acceptable that Ukrainian planes still fly...the Ukrainians use roads as improvised airfields! video on @milinfolive Telegram channel

    ATLASCUB
    ATLASCUB


    Posts : 1154
    Points : 1158
    Join date : 2017-02-13

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  ATLASCUB Sat Sep 10, 2022 9:03 pm

    Pretend American soldier for the final trolling finish. lol1

    It has indeed gone off-the-rails.
    ---------------

    Russian military explains partial withdrawal

    https://www.rt.com/russia/562559-mod-explains-withdrawal/

    Russian units have left multiple settlements in the Kharkov region amid a Ukrainian offensive

    The Russian Defense Ministry has confirmed the withdrawal of troops from multiple locations across Ukraine’s Kharkov region. The development comes amid a offensive in the area by Kiev.

    “In order to achieve the goals of the special military operation, a decision was made to regroup troops in the areas of Balakleya and Izyum in order to build up efforts in the Donetsk direction,” the Russian military said in a statement on Saturday.

    The troops stationed in the area have been "re-deployed" over the past three days into territory of the Donetsk People’s Republic, the ministry claimed. During the operation, the military has performed a “number of distracting and demonstration activities imitating the real action of troops,” it added, without providing any further detail on said maneuvers.

    In order to prevent “damage to Russian troops,” the military has been subjecting Ukrainian units in the area to “powerful” artillery, missile and aircraft attacks, the ministry said, claiming destruction of over 100 armor pieces and artillery, as well as elimination of “more than 2,000 Ukrainian and foreign fighters” in the past three days.

    The withdrawal comes amid a massive Ukrainian offensive that was launched in Kharkov Region on Thursday. The assault was preceded by attempts to advance in other areas, namely near the Russia-controlled southern Ukrainian city of Kherson.
    SeigSoloyvov
    SeigSoloyvov


    Posts : 3721
    Points : 3701
    Join date : 2016-04-08

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  SeigSoloyvov Sat Sep 10, 2022 9:22 pm

    ATLASCUB wrote:Pretend American soldier for the final trolling finish. lol1

    It has indeed gone off-the-rails.
    ---------------

    Russian military explains partial withdrawal

    https://www.rt.com/russia/562559-mod-explains-withdrawal/

    Russian units have left multiple settlements in the Kharkov region amid a Ukrainian offensive

    The Russian Defense Ministry has confirmed the withdrawal of troops from multiple locations across Ukraine’s Kharkov region. The development comes amid a offensive in the area by Kiev.

    “In order to achieve the goals of the special military operation, a decision was made to regroup troops in the areas of Balakleya and Izyum in order to build up efforts in the Donetsk direction,” the Russian military said in a statement on Saturday.

    The troops stationed in the area have been "re-deployed" over the past three days into territory of the Donetsk People’s Republic, the ministry claimed. During the operation, the military has performed a “number of distracting and demonstration activities imitating the real action of troops,” it added, without providing any further detail on said maneuvers.

    In order to prevent “damage to Russian troops,” the military has been subjecting Ukrainian units in the area to “powerful” artillery, missile and aircraft attacks, the ministry said, claiming destruction of over 100 armor pieces and artillery, as well as elimination of “more than 2,000 Ukrainian and foreign fighters” in the past three days.

    The withdrawal comes amid a massive Ukrainian offensive that was launched in Kharkov Region on Thursday. The assault was preceded by attempts to advance in other areas, namely near the Russia-controlled southern Ukrainian city of Kherson.

    Oh look excuses from the Russian MOD

    owais.usmani likes this post

    GarryB
    GarryB


    Posts : 39169
    Points : 39667
    Join date : 2010-03-30
    Location : New Zealand

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  GarryB Sat Sep 10, 2022 9:38 pm

    IF the Russian plan was to draw the UA out from their protected defensive lines into the open in large enough numbers to impact on the key objective of Kharkov city, especially perhaps the die hard units, it needed to be a very realistic, large scale and achievable.

    There is no IF about it... the Russians have repeatedly used their mobility and fire power advantage to move and fight... anywhere the Orcs have attacked that attack has either been crushed because it was pathetic, or they pulled back and let them come forward and then smash them with air power and artillery.

    That is how you fight an enemy with superior numbers.

    The Russian occupy positions but the Orcs are free to attack anywhere they please and when they attack they attack in small concentrations to ensure local superiority in numbers that are enormous.... the don't spread out along the entire line and march slowly forwards, they concentrate their forces they think are weak or vulnerable and  concentrate all their attacking forces there.

    Claiming the Russians are incompetent for not moving troops to the expected lines of attack ignores the fact that the Orcs are not stupid... if Russia moved massive forces in to meet this attack the Orcs would just start shelling those concentrations of forces and attack somewhere else.

    You don't attack the enemy line in places where they are the strongest unless it is a diversion to distract them from the real attack somewhere else.

    This wasn't a Russian plan it was a general Russian goal... the Orcs have been talking about their great counter attack that will get them to the Crimea... this was supposed to be it.

    So, on the one hand it had to be militarily viable and on the other, if it could be timed to coincide with the 8th September Ramstein donors' meeting it would irresistible to the top US/UK/Ukr politicians' PR objectives. A slam dunk in other words.

    And attack by them or an attack by Russia would have suited their needs just fine... they don't have to launch anything... they could just lie about it... would not be their first lie.

    This would be all about the lessor of two evils. We know that the Russian military strategy is very mathematical. This could have been where the algorithms at the Moscow MoD showed the best return of dead UA versus dead Russian UA citizens/military over the next few weeks.

    The Russians have been receiving counter attacks from the Orcs for some time now and they follow the same course... the orcs concentrate their forces and the Russians mow them down if they can, if they can't the kill as many as they can and retreat in order... as the orcs move forward they will come under artillery and air strike attacks till they run out of steam... they keep getting hammered and then when they start to retreat they keep getting hit... losing men moving forward and going back in huge numbers.

    This was a major push with lots more men that usual but the recipe has not changed...  moving extra forces up to the line so they can hold out against any Orc attack is just concentrating forces for enemy artillery to attack and enemy attacks to bypass.

    Actually he is as pro russian as you. If he admits such thing it is true.

    But unlike me is never wrong?


    @ Garryb , if it was planned they wouldn't be stuffing the entire area with mobile groups from every direction -

    You are standing your ground and I am in front of you and you know I am going to punch you... what are your plans?

    The Russian forces held a line on a battlefield and the Orcs formed up forces to attack that line... they formed up very large forces of men to attack that line.

    Since the start of this conflict the tactics have been not to mass lots of Russian meat in front of Orc meat and have some bloody blood bath... the Russian tactic has been to roll back with any attempted attack by the Orcs.... smaller weaker attacks are obliterated with their superior firepower and artillery and air power support, but in this case the orcs simply had too many men amassed in the attack so you fall back and you damage him as you go ripping in to his forces as they blunder forward with your weapons and also artillery and air power. Eventually they will reach a limit where their support and supply run out and then you can stop them and you continue to pound them and destroy them with your superior fire power and support... in this case you can move in larger support forces to help bolster the forces you are using in the fighting because tiny forces should never be expected to wipe out large forces.

    Eventually the Orc forces are going to be exhausted and destroyed... attack is rather more costly than defence and 100 times more so when you don't control the air and your artillery is thin and scared shitless of being pinged.

    "It's all a 5D chess cunning plan"

    No need for 5D chess planning... the orcs massed their forces for local superiority in numbers and they are pushing them forward like a WWI conflict engagement on the western front... the difference is that the Russian forces are fully mobile and so were not overrun and defeated... they fell back and continued to hammer the enemy as it blindly marched forward into their artillery and air strikes... they will probably move in extra fire power to deal with this and a huge chunk of the Orcs army will be rotting in the fields.

    That's the fucking job of russian soldiers!!! Protecting russian civilians...if they die they die it's their job! Are people in east Ukraine ethnic russians or maybe ethnic germans, ethnic chinese or whatever? They want to make these territories russian in a few weeks, so you can't betray these people!

    They are not betraying anyone, all the men in these regions should be signing up to the Lugansk or Donbass forces and protecting their own... the old men and women and children should be moved out of this war zone till the job has been done.

    The nazis have shown their nature and there is no question what they do so everyone should be moved as the Russian forces move in to any area.

    Those that refuse... well then that is on their heads.

    Some will always refuse to leave their homes... nothing you can do about that.

    Complete BULLSHIT! If the Russian Army leave in a matter of hours while you sitting in bunker, how you can react fast enough? I have no information that russian side has evacuated the civilians, they are in death trap now! You point is very inhumane...I hope you know it!

    Humane has nothing to do with it... these are the realities of war. the Russian soldiers are the tools that are defeating the nazis that are doing this sort of thing all over the country every day... they are not just doing this in recaptured areas, they are doing it in all occupied areas... when they find what they believe are sympathisers they kill them... can Russian soldiers save them?

    They can save them all by defeating these bastards.

    Bullshit again! The people voted for pro-russian parties, during the Maidan time they organized an uprising....people of Crimea voted many time for independence. What else should they do??? What else?

    The first chance they get they move east to safer territory and wait out the war and send their young men to help the effort to eliminate these nazis.


    Things are getting dire for the russians in that area, just goes to show lack of troops is a problem

    If the Russians had more troops there they would have attacked somewhere else.

    [quote]Nobody is shouting that. People can actually criticize Russian leadership while still being for Russia. Someone fucked up and that's obvious. It can be fixed, true, but it shouldn't suppose to happen in the first place. We are not at the beginning of operation anymore. [/quoet]

    I will be shouting soon... you keep going on about this fuckup, but essentially what has happened is that Russian troops occupy certain areas and villages and Orcs occupy others and what has happened is that the Orcs massed up a very big force of men and some armour and they have attacked Russian held positions... gaining enormous superiority in numbers in very local areas... like anyone would do when they attack, and of course the Russians fired back and withdrew while continuing to kill Orcs with their weapons and of course air power and artillery.

    Moving Russian forces to places they thought the Orcs might have attacked would simply make the Orcs change their plans and attack somewhere else... in war things happen for reasons so if you move forces around then enemy attacks change too making that moving around a little pointless until the attack has begun.

    When you are holding a line you don't move reserves up to hold a line before an attack starts... where do you move it to?

    And if you do the enemy will notice and attack somewhere else or might just shell your now concentrated position.

    Sending VDV like that would be suicidal and completely stupid. Ukrainians still have a lot of anti-aircraft systems.amd Il-76 would be easy target.

    Would have to agree with you there... armour heavy forces and concentrated artillery and air power would be better for this job of stopping the advances and just hammering the forces, their reserves and supply columns and then use mobile forces to rip them to pieces.

    Little Garry going back to the trash bin to the old "not Russian" "pick yourself up by your bootstraps" talking points.  Jesus!

    Amusing you mention Jesus... wonder what Jesus would think about western support for these nazis and support for ISIS and your (western) other crimes...


    The beauty of fvck ups is that new talking points from the top don't get disseminated as fast as the action develops.

    Obviously fuckups happen, but this is an Orc engineered made up fuckup, they have thrown thousands of men into the meat grinder to beg for more weapons... to thrown more men into the meat grinder... Russia should be celebrating.

    Russia has the second best and capable air force in the world and they use it only homeopathic, because they fear every loss.

    I disagree... it has never been a Russian belief that everything can be solved by air power... that is a western thing and it largely stems from how they won both theatres of WWII with their strategic bombing of Germany and Japan...

    And they fear the loss of every soldier, in contrast Ukraine doesn't care and conquered in 7 days more territory than Russia in 3 months.

    It is not about gaining territory, it is about eliminating the enemy army and in the last 7 days the Ukrainian army probably lost more men than it lost in the first two months of the conflict... and to do that they are draining men from all the other areas they occupy... do the maths yourself... who is being smart here...


    That's the problem...if you flip every coin thousand times before spending and your are not willing to send conscripts or make a partial mobilisation...that are the results!!!

    It has nothing to do with spending, and they are not running out of ordinance as fast as Kiev will be running out of men.

    A lot of people misconstrue what the criticism of the SMO actually is-

    Seems to me to be panic at hearing bad news from very unreliable sources who want you to panic and change tactics because the current tactics are WORKING.

    No way this is planned by the Russians.

    How could they plan an Orc attack?

    This is simply well played by the West, doing a good job at rapidly moving around forces (disregarding obviously the huge losses on Ukranian side).

    Not at all... the best plan the west could implement is for Kievs forces to dig in and stay dug in and hold out for as long as they can mingled in with civilians.

    This has gotten thousands of Kievs soldiers to march out towards the Russian forces and get killed... the pushed the Russians back by sending more soldiers than the Russians could deal with at once... that is not a good plan... that is a stupid disasterous plan that is going to get Ukrainian men exterminated... maybe that is the plan, but it is not clever.

    The Russians knew such an attack was comming but failed to identify exactly where, and failed to react fast enough or IMHO.

    But they did react fast enough.... as far as we know no Russian forces were encircled and wiped out... they moved back while inflicting horrendous losses on the enemy... as capture and occupation of territory is not their goal, their goal is to eliminate enemy soldiers raising weapons to fire at them, then this was a resounding success for the Russians.

    If the Ukrops start another assault like this on another weak spot in the defences, then the whole SMO will be in a hard spot.

    The thing is that I rather doubt the Orcs have enough men to do this again... and if they did the rest of their defences will collapse because the few that are left will know they are next and they wont want to follow the soldiers currently getting slaughtered in the fields.


    It was posted already. Here's my take. Imagine Russia did mobilize and run over the country to Kiev. Destroyed the govt and civilian infrastructure. It would be like Iraq 2003. Yes Russia could swing it's dick and show how powerful they are. But the Ukraine military would still be out there. Not destroyed. There would be an insurgency. There'd be civil chaos. It would really a like Iraq post 2003.

    A direct result of that was ISIS.

    But perhaps there is a middle ground. Maybe Russia could have semi mobilized. And sped up some of these regional battles.

    But why would they... Ukrainian counter attacks are achieving Russian goals just fine.

    Same goes for foreign mercenaries. They're a finite resource and their enthusiasm for this war has long since passed its peak. It didn't help that they in many cases were sent as cannon fodder with an AK, one magazine of ammo - straight to Kiev to soak up Russian firepower back when the city was under threat.

    More importantly those foreign mercenaries range from geeks in some paint ball team, to actual professional western trained soldiers that have been to real conflicts the west loves to start who know what real war actually is, but have not been on the receiving end of artillery and air power in an armed force that cannot return in kind and just has to hunker down and take it.

    Against third world countries whose only response is IEDs and VIEDs then being a soldier is easy, but when the enemy is equipped with first world stuff and your side is not you are not any better equipped to withstand enemy artillery as an untrained fool beside you... this is not a video game where you can go off and do your own thing, you follow orders and of course they are going to use foreigners first as cannon fodder.

    The buildup of Ukranian forces here was noted on social media 1-2 weeks ago.

    If the Russia missed that, it's a next-level embarrasment.

    Why move more forces into the area... they would just attack somewhere else.... and where were they going to attack before they attack... did you know?

    I guess the command thought they where bluffing and expected "the big push" to come in a different area?

    It doesn't matter where the big push came from... the plan has not changed.... if the enemy attack hit them with artillery and air power and shoot them as they move forward while Russian forces withdraw... keep hammering them until they can't move forward any more and are exhausted and keep hitting them till they withdraw... including hitting any support units or supply units you find.

    That's what happens when you leave transport infrastructure intact. They can take whole brigades from Nikolaev to Kharkhov in one night.

    If they can't move forces forward to attack how can Russian forces mow them down?

    Even if i do agree about some of your points, presenting this as some sort of a trap set up by Russians, i don't buy

    It is not a trap as such, it has been the plan all along...

    It is how they take advantage of their superior artillery and air support.

    I would be surprised if the Ukes could concentrate this kind of force without the Russians knowing, if they did kudos to them and a razzy to the Russian commanders and satellite intel. So its either a trap or **** up. If its a fuckup, its then being compounded by slow response of air power to take out logistics. How Ukraine is still getting this much diesel to power their machines is a big fail, said that for while. If Russia cannot stop the flow of diesel they will pay for it with a flow of blood.

    Why would the Russians do anything to stop this blood bath... Orcs were killed in enormous numbers... they gained a little territory... but for how long and at what cost?

    They wont be able to do this every week but I hope they try because every time they do this they get closer to collapse.

    Defeating Russian artillery by sending in more troops than they could deal with sounds like the sort of planning that loses wars.

    Biggest grouping of Ukrainian military was always around Kharkhov. And they could always bring several brigades via rail network.

    And if they tried to send brigades like that, would that not be the best time to hit those bridges and trains?


    First mine kill of the war , depending on if Moskva was done in by mines like they say

    Kiev wants to claim credit for its sinking so they claim they hit it with missiles... once you make that claim of course you can't then say it was a mine...

    They couldn't spot ukrinians getting 10k troops at a same place.

    What makes you think they weren't spotted... maybe they wanted them marching forward into registered artillery kill zones before shredding them.

    Su-24R would help but aren't used. Satelittes should have detected this but it seems ukrainians hided their forces very well.

    As mentioned they have been talking about a big push for some time, and all the fuel dumps and ammo dumps and HQs that get hit all the time suggests their intel is not that bad...

    Lack of armed drones is still critical for russians.

    Armed drones are as useless as tits on a bull when faced with 10K enemy troops marching forward.

    What sort of hand grenade payload or Kornet missile payload on armed drones can deal with a force of 10 thousand men marching forward on a battlefield... even a thousand drones would be useless because the thousands of men operating them wont be shooting at the bad guys.

    All i said, from the beginning, is that someone in command of the Balakleya theater fucked up. Trying to present this as some sort of a pre-planned trap is emotional, imo.

    Russian forces have a clear track history throughout this conflict of using mobility and fire power to deal with superior numbers of the enemy... in this case the enemy massed more troops that usual and attacked and took enormous casualties but through sheer weight of numbers managed to gain some territory, and some here wet their pants and cry for Putin and the Russian military to all be fired for incompetence.

    Ignoring the fact that this is what Russia has been doing all along.... a small counter attack is dealt with by the forces themselves defeating them with fire power. Larger counter attacks the Russians might need to withdraw but they are not throwing down their weapons and running away in a rout... they are withdrawing in order inflicting damage on the enemy and as the enemy move in to the positions the Russians held the Russian artillery can then shell the crap out of them because they know where they will be hiding.... the enemy often then retreats and the Russian forces move back to occupy their previous positions and probably clean up the mess.

    In this case they massed more meat that usual so it probably took more artillery than normal to deal with but to mass that extra meat they are draining areas they occupy and speeding up their defeat... this is not bad for Russian forces... this is fantastic that they are this stupid to accelerate their own demise like this.


    But if you criticize you're on the shitlist

    Criticising the Russians for butchering Orc soldiers in large numbers does put you on a shit list because you are essentially rooting for Kievs forces.


    What was more like a standstill for weeks, the enemy has achieved brave operation over two days. Initiative almost without air cover. Of course these are NATO commands. Of course, this operation is a NATO operation.

    If this is how HATO plans to fight this is excellent... really outstanding... trading lots of men for a piece of land they are not likely to even hold on to... fantastic.

    So Pro-Russians being raped, tortured, and executed are being ignored?

    Russian sources already reported it, now westerners are gloating.

    A woman with a British, American and Kiev flag next to her name is gloating at civilians potentially being murdered because she could care less about the 10K young Ukrainian men who just got butchered and turned into red mist... best described as a coping strategy.

    What an empty souled heartless bitch.

    What mental gymnastics do you need to practice to think that another Bucha x10 is ok?

    Nazis committing more war crimes... what else do you expect from them... but it is Russias fault...

    No settlements should be allowed to be taken by Ukrainians without evacuation.

    Most of these people refuse to leave their homes.

    There's an emergency meeting, we will see what exactly he likes.

    Perhaps he wanted to be updated as to what is happening...


    Oh she did, she wiped out 300 billion dollars worth of assets

    , debit bad debt expense, credit allowance for bad debt

    Lmao

    I don't make the rules man, I just tell it like it is

    First of all it is nothing like 300 billion and if the west does steal that money then Russia can do the same with western assets in Russia so no money lost at all.


    Nonetheless it's kinda sad. job of Russian soldiers are to protect the Russian people which should include the settlement they take.

    A lot of these civilians might not want to be Russians, this is the Ukraine.

    Russian command didn't expect this because it is inherently insane and irrational. This is an isis style suicide run. It is all done for propaganda purposes. And it sure doesn't help when Russia supporters feed the narrative

    If you ignore the chicken littles this is fantastic news... a huge number of Orcs just met their maker and a horrendous rate and the orcs think it is a victory.... hopefully they will keep doing this and it will be over much faster.

    at least you can admit it

    And still other things need to be corrected

    But alas we are just peasants

    Again, noone said hohols will win - who gives a shit about narrative?

    Just get the results then noone will worry about narrative

    Russian command could not have anticipated the Orcs would be this stupid but they will be celebrating that they quite clearly are... the Russian forces probably just butchered thousands of Orcs as easy as you please... all they had to do was withdraw a little to do so... all those ambulances... 90% of Orc activity on the front line was probably carrying wounded back to evac locations, or being wounded themselves...

    I'd bomb the cities like Syria, evacuate civilians and do this

    Hilarious... how do you evacuate civilians from cities you do not occupy... and if you bomb cities without a civilian evacuation then why all the crying about Nazi war crimes against some civilians when you want to bomb all them yourself.

    How many russian vehicles have the ukrainians captured in this offensive?

    I would say we would see plenty of photos of captured or destroyed Russian vehicles... the Russians likely withdrew... which as has been mentioned is what they are supposed to do while the artillery and air power do their work.

    Guys I would also check india defense net forum time to time, they bring up some interesting things like russia just launched a missile at a hospital, which means I guess that they are pissed.

    It means Kiev has liars in India too... firing missiles at hospitals is a waste of a missile, there are plenty of real targets to hit instead.

    It would be nice to take the city, but it is too expensive in terms of lost men and civilians. I do not think that Russia intends to storm any major city
    where the regime is entrenched. This includes Odessa. Let's see where these 9,000 Kiev regime troops end up in the coming days.

    Encircling cities would cut them off from Kiev so they can't use the men as conscripts and cannon fodder... might even get a few cities to surrender and get some volunteers to deal with the Kiev regime too, but at the worst it reduces the pool of bodies they can weaponise and throw at Russian bullets and shells.

    What we call Russia today was created by the Russian Church and the Russian Empire, which the Reds could not destroy.

    As most of you know I am an athiest, but to be honest I think Russia is the most ethical and moral country on the planet right now and I would rate the west as more soulless and evil than the athiest Commies.

    its just sounded like a **** up(thats what humiliation is) when Russia sent more re-enforcements and Putin having a random meeting.

    The Orcs mounted an attack that cost them an enormous number of men and doesn't seem to have hurt Russian forces to any great extent.

    Kiev is going to struggle to replace those losses, while the territory they captured they probably are in no position to hold and will likely lose it and lose even more soldiers in their retreat... assuming any make it out of there... hopefully they will pump more soldiers in to maximise the death toll.

    This is fantastic.

    Being pissed that Ukrianians even had a chance for this nonsense and them targeting civilians is not doomerism. Russia will still win the war, but this shouldn’t happen. I hope they will be cut off from retreat and Vostok will show its results

    They have been targeting pro Russian civilians for the last 8 years... is that Putins fault too... are Russian soldiers to blame?

    “The time of reckoning has come,” the SBI concluded.

    Amusing because their time of reckoning is coming too.

    I don't think random poster on telegram or Russia defense forum are "enabling" NATO propaganda

    I think the leadership has done fine on its own

    When you repeat Orc propaganda then you are helping HATO.

    The leadership are just fine... the plan is continuing as normal and the results are just dandy... traded a salient bulge for the enemy to pour troops in to at high cost to them of course... and now it is play time.

    It is the game they have been playing for months and it is working well... it seems this bulge contains some of their newly trained super soldiers... but what training teaches you to survive artillery barrages?

    It is 100% on leadership

    Don't take shit from these "everything is going according to plan" guzzlers

    People will die because of their incompetence

    Yes, people are dying, because Nazis are murdering them and that is why Russian forces are there in the first place.

    Russia is withdrawing from cities with tens of thousands of people, allowing Ukrops to carry out reprisals against those who cooperated, as some sort of plan? Lol

    It is OK, they will be fine because America would not allow any war crimes to be committed... they have ethics and morals that will prevent them from arming such people who kill their own civilians... except for Israel of course, and ISIS, and most of the other nutters they support.

    I think you'd have to have the IQ of an ape to think this is part of a plan, but if that's what you believe, you do you.

    They didn't invade the country with enough troops to hold territory, during this whole campain they have used mobility and fire power to destroy their enemy... this desperate attack by the orcs is just another attack by them... larger in scale, but nothing new, and the Russians continue to use the same tactics... light forces holding the line with mobile reserves sent to any point of serious resistance or attack while the forces present fall back in a fighting retreat.

    That is the plan and that is what they are following.

    Call me an ape again and you are banned from this forum.

    And if it was part of a plan, does that mean no Ukrainian should ever cooperate with the allies because at any moment they could be abandoned and left to torture and executing by Ukrops as part of a scheme?

    Russia cannot control what the Orcs do, all they can do is kill them and that is what they are doing. The orcs can attack where they please when they please and all Russia can do is kill them when they do so.

    You are comparing ISIS to the Armed Forces of Ukraine, the latter of which is receiving billions in funding per month from NATO powers, along with advanced NATO and especially US precision weaponry, and is receiving live coordination via video-link by NATO commanders, plus of course clandestine assets on the ground.

    ISIS was never stupid enough to think their best way to defeat Russian fire power superiority in artillery and air power was to mount human wave attacks to make them run low on ammo.

    It takes special HATO planning to be that smart... it seems HATO wants the Orcs dead as much as the Russians do... so that is good news.

    Wait but wasn't SMO... to liberate pro russian people oppressed by Ukrainians?

    It was to eliminate a nazi, bio, and potentially future nuclear threat to Russia... if they have to kill lots of Ukrainians then that is what they will do.

    I am really surprised the Russians do not have a quick reaction force of about 20 US-34's or SU-24 that are ready to be loaded up and deliver 30-50t of bombs in rotating 5 ship formations to stabilize just this sort of thing. I would also be pretty surprised of an intelligence failure of this magnitude...if it were that.

    Yeah, the thing is that even bomb attacks have to be coordinated and worked out otherwise you end up bombing friendlies or civilians or nothing at all.

    SBU is working overtime catching wrongthinkers. But you have to agree it’s sensitive topic and it can bite in the ass if those executions will be proven true and nothing was done to prevent them. I see more people worried about that than territory. I am myself not bothered about Russia regaining lands at all. Just worried it will be devoid of life.

    Perhaps the civilians need to rise up against the SBU... if you have been helping the Russians or just working with them... pick up a rifle and defend yourself.... become a partisan... what is the alternative future for you if you are too stubborn to leave?

    Moderation at times makes no sense I think I remember PD got a temporary ban being displeased at the start of the war for like a week or two(or he stopped posting to cool off)

    No he didn't. He got a break for claiming Russian troops were bloody idiots (or words to that effect) for following orders to invade the Ukraine because at the time he did not approve of the conflict.

    I was displeased for a month and even now as to how much progress has been made. Are we like 15 % out of 100% from killing all hohols have we killed 33% out of 100% hohols and still being stuck with 1/3rd territory when will we push to 1/2 territory and ukrainians getting supplied more and more with weapons will make people like me here ask what amount of progress is made?

    Throwing their recently newly western trained super soldiers into the meat grinder like they are currently doing is accelerating the process... if they do this a couple more times the areas outside their little counter attacks are going to be so thinly protected that Russia will be able to do to them what they are trying to do to Russia except the Orcs don't have the mobile reserves the Russians have and they also don't have the concentration of artillery and air power at their disposal either...


    I will give this thread another chance but if some shit like this happens again and Russias is still stuck where its at, i will disappear from this thread for a month to stop myself from further getting pissed off.

    Promise?

    Can some Generals in Ukraine army post on this and other forums ?

    Ukrainian Generals spent the last 8 years shelling Ukrainian citizens and justified it by saying it is OK because they are actually Russian civilians... which is a war crime by the way.

    Except when the west does it with their strategic bombing and then they say it isn't a war crime because it is total war.

    According to some forum members everything is according to some mysterious plan.

    There is nothing mysterious about how the Russians have been fighting... nothing has changed... the Russians are fighting smart and the Orcs are fighting stupid and getting hammered... nothing has changed except the Orcs got together rather more cannon fodder than they normally put together and it seems they are running out of men.

    Okay to be true I sound a bit like a defeatist Very Happy

    A bit?

    You distort the facts the way a US State Department speech writer would...

    Zelensky will give you your medal now you nazi.  Shame really... normally liked what you posted. Hope that big cheque you got for this will pay for heating this winter...

    And about experienced soldiers...and training...after 6 months you can make out of degenerated retards good soldiers.

    You mean like the 250K soldiers they had at the start of this conflict and the 2,000 odd tanks they had and all the other stuff they had that is gone now.

    If they keep feeding their amazing HATO super soldiers into battle like this then that is fantastic...

    Sorry for being hard and unpolite!!! But the situation now is a real problem!

    Only for traitors like yourself.

    Ukraine gains more than you think! They will gain new material from western Nazi world...maybe some modern MBTs (Abrams or Leopard 2), for sure they will get Iris-T SLM and NASAMS, more APCs and of course money and ammunition. And they gained territory.

    I hope they do give them Abrams and Leopards, that crap is over rated and it will justify Russia selling Su-35s to Iran and North Korea...

    And cutting gas and oil and coal to the EU.

    It's called criticism and it's legit! Without criticism you can't evolve...you will stuck in your old place and make the same mistakes again and again till you disappear from world stage.

    So doing just as nothing happened would be better?

    No it isn't. You are supporting nazis and criticising those eradicating them because you are a pussy and think a force moving forward must be winning.

    There are reports that Russia is withdrawing from Liman. Ukraine has set up successfully a pontoon bridge and is flooding the area.

    Voices in your head?

    Hitler or Georbells?

    Wheres big gazza podlodka and kvs to say losing izyum is a nothingburger?

    The Orcs are rushing their enemy and getting slaughtered in the process... did it not make you wonder that maybe reports of further retreats might be to encourage Kiev to push more troops into the fire?

    Where are the field hospitals that NATO could have been supplying from their stocks to maximise life and limb saving in the Golden Hour?

    Sorry not enough profit in their replacement. Or even, medics were not a priority when NATO upgraded the Ukie army so there is no point.

    Instead the encourage mindless attacks like they did with Snake Island... almost like they hate the Ukrainians as much as they hate Russians and want as many dead as possible.

    The only relevant part of the Russkie withdrawal is the fact, that they have left behind some loyal population and people who cooperated with the new authorities.

    You mean like the US and HATO left behind Afghans that helped them in Kabul to the whims of the Taliban and ISIS... you need to keep in mind that a lot of the population in these areas will cooperate with what ever military force is in charge and so when the Orcs arrive the Ukrainian flags and Ukrainian passports will come out and they will be singing the national anthem of the Ukraine... just like in the Outlaw Josey Wales movie where that barge owner was pretending to be on one side and then the opposition arrived and all of a sudden he was singing dixie...

    The Russians have fought this operation with a very small number of troops on the ground... This week that caught up with them.

    But has it?

    If Russia sends in more men and starts defending towns to protect civilians you just know the Orcs are going to shell those towns because they know it will upset the Russians. The west wont give a shit...

    If there are thousands of dead Orcs and thousands more trapped then I would say the plan is working just fine... continue with the harvest...

    careful don't criticize the narrative that there is enough troops

    The job is killing your nazis proxy forces and that is happening so everything going to plan.

    if Izyum is lost that is a huge huge loss.

    I am sure the usually spin doctors will try to downplay it.

    The russians fucked up here and massively.

    Holding towns is bullshit, killing orcs is what it is all about and they seem to be doing rather better than normal...


    Oh wow on the defense now, you are one of the ones that claim the number of troops was enough and now when its beyond clear it isn't you try this?

    This level of troop numbers and their deployment has been fine up until now, but now the Nazis are trying to beat the Russians by getting them to use all their ammo up.

    Well that requires a change in tactics and force structure, but that is fine... just a new phase of this conflict that will accelerate the process of destroying Nazis in bulk.

    Declaring war is just a formality. How much more would nato escalate? They already escalated to the maximum

    The nazis have been killing their own people for a decade now... if you want Russia to declare war on Ukraine over Ukrainian citizens who are pro Russia then perhaps a declaration of war against the Baltic states over their treatment of their Russian citizens is in order too?

    This is simple I believe, if Russia increases the number of soldiers in Ukraine, they will destroy the Ukronazis.

    It is funny, those demanding Russia sends in more men and calls it a proper war ignore that such an escalation will end up killing rather more civilians than even the nazis can manage... you know... like the US did in Iraq and Afghanistan and Libya and Syria and everywhere else they have bombed.

    I'm not happy about the civilians in Balakleya and whereever else but that's the only part of the Russian strategy that's flawed. They should have evacuated people and had measures in place for that. Even if they didn't want to go.

    They know the people they are fighting, if the civilians didn't leave then it is on them.

    sepheronx, flamming_python, Big_Gazza, kvs, BliTTzZ, Hole, Backman and like this post

    GarryB
    GarryB


    Posts : 39169
    Points : 39667
    Join date : 2010-03-30
    Location : New Zealand

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  GarryB Sat Sep 10, 2022 9:39 pm

    A great plan to have the civilians slaughtered by fascists! Maybe let the Ukronazis straight to Belgorod or maybe Moscow? You can save soo many Russian soldiers... civilians are expendables.

    Wouldn't be the first time, which makes you wonder why the civilians don't leave... how many will actually be killed... these Orc forces are not huge and I doubt they are carrying a lot of ammo with them. If they start murdering civilians they might find they start getting shot at by some civilians who expect better from their compatriots.

    Or something else... who cares.

    To be serious now....you really believe this shit of a great plan? Maybe if there is a great plan for a big Russian counteroffensive....Russia betrayed the civilians here! My estimation are more than 100000 civilians left in this area. Here are not some small villages and the retreat of Russian Forces was too hastily... civilians couldn't react that fast.

    That is OK... it is Russias plan... once the nazis have used up all their ammo shooting all those civilians they will be easy pickings for small groups of Russian soldiers who do have plenty of ammo.

    Russia has damaged it's own image of a liberator making the liberation of the regions more complicated. Do you really believe the people of Kharkov or Odessa will cheer if the Russians show up, knowing they will leave in the blink of a second if shit is going serious?

    They are there to kill enemy soldiers. You think US soldiers gave a shit about Afghans or Iraqis or Syrians?

    Biggest looser of the war is the su-34. Junk aircraft. Su-35 was successful when used but can't be used for close support. Su-25/ka-52/mi-28 used as MLRS system.

    They probably have more Su-34s than Su-35s... but please inform us of the details of the Su-34s failings.

    And from MOD still crickets.

    If they tell Kiev it is a trap then Kiev might stop feeding meat into the trap.

    This retreat from Kharkov is reminding me of the retreat from Kiev a few months back. I don't understand the point of this SMO anymore. Is the point for Russia to embarrass itself and look weak on the world stage? Are they even truly trying to win this war anymore? WTF is going on?

    They just lost thousands of men and thousands more are deployed in a large bulge in their line.

    When the enemy fall back and you follow them and then get hammered by their air power and artillery that is not a rout or any sort of defeat.

    Putin is an overrated leader and the army is not what we thought it was. They're scared that if they go all out they'll be labeled "war criminals". Pathetic leadership from top to bottom. I feel sorry for the poor soldiers who have died and been wounded for this crummy midget named Putin and that doofus Shoigu.

    Putin would have no say in the planning of this conflict... he will set the goals but have nothing at all to do with the actual operational plans of the military... do you think Boris Johnson planned operations in Afghanistan?

    Well maybe he has planned operations for Kiev... that would explain a lot.

    Ok oh infinitely wise one: whats the logic in the russians completely abandoning kharkov oblast and moving to donbass?

    Maybe their experience of being there made them feel unsafe because there were so many nazis civilians there that they decided it wasn't worth saving... let the orcs take it... and I doubt the forces they moved forward with were particularly suited to taking cities and towns apart from raising flags and taking photos of course... and then  let them have at it with the locals left behind.

    Seems like your dumbass doesn't want to live in reality. You'd rather lie to yourself than live in truth.

    Your opinion and the opinion of other nazis does not constitute truth.

    How many russian soldiers died here to liberate these territories? I think many thousands of russian soldiers, because Kharkov was one of the hottest spots in the war. And you simply shit on the graves of these heroes! Shame on you!!!

    They died killing nazis and nazi supporters like you, who remain dead, but why send more to join them to save ungrateful nazi sympathisers who wont lift a finger to help themselves.


    That's what clowns like you said when they retreated from Kiev. Kharkov is lost.

    Taking Kiev was never a goal... they never had even a fraction of the forces to take Kiev so it was never on the table.

    I agree with that conclusion. But how do you come from a tactical **** up in the region around Balakleya to this? In a matter of few days? Wasn't there any second line of defense deployed at all?

    Why have a second line of defence? The first line of defence rolls back with any attack and withdraws while keeping the enemy under fire all the way while artillery and air power do the actual killing.

    Do the math! With this speed the war will go on for 3-10 years. If you count only the territorial gains of Russian Army in the last 3 months the war will be over in over 50 years.

    The west can't afford to keep funding Kiev for 10 years let alone 3... these are loans that the west will need paid back.... Russia certainly isn't going to pay.

    Who do you think in UA forces are taking the brunt of casualties?

    They will have conscripts and also western trained soldiers, the conscripts will be sacrificed to get the better trained troops to where they are going, but those better trained troops are going to die too.

    At this point, will it be a crazy thing if Russia starts retreating from parts of Kherson as well? I'm sure the Putin sycophants on here will explain to us that this is actually a brilliant tactical retreat and Russia will actually trap the Ukronazis and drive them back at some future undisclosed date. This is where we're at...ridiculous.

    Maybe they will withdraw all the way to the Crimea... and then attack and advance all the way to Kiev... who knows, who cares, not my decision, not my problem.

    Nazis are getting killed at accelerating rates so I am happy.

    In an airspace protected by rafale and typhoon with meteor and f-35s with aim120D it has no value.

    When have they ever protected any real airspace... Tu-123 drones fly through four or five HATO states unnoticed. Civilian planes fly across borders and are ignored... HATO air defence is a joke even compared with current Orc defences.

    Russian AD is also getting destroyed and isn't bulletproof as they advize it for years, even if it is quite capable.

    Western AD is open to drones and cruise missiles. No one ever said Russian AD is perfect.

    This was a big **** up in Kharkov but once the reinforcements arrive, the situation will stabilize.

    It was not a **** up, it was an Orc attack... such things happen during war.

    In the meantime the western propaganda machine will go into overdrive and the west will send more money and weapons and most of that will be stolen.

    You call them armchair generals but they are just western propaganda... almost certainly preop...

    I'm sure Putin is sad about all this, while he wipes his tears with stolen money, resting in his lavish mansion dressed in his bathrobe.

    In his secret base on the far side of the moon... the mansion between Elvis and Hitler.


    The Putin government is under fire and is in danger of complete loss of confidence- people in Russia are organizing protests

    So Western bots are pretending they are Russians and trying to start a colour revolution...

    The sweet irony is that to get back Russian support from such pussies all Putin needs to do is authorise Zelenskys demise and as many of his fellow nazis as possible and then things will be fine.

    You can read maps? Can you?

    Do you understand maps may have nothing at all to do with reality and anyone can edit a map to say anything they please... including showing Orc forces at the gates of Moscow...

    Locking the thread would be the worse thing ever

    Look you guys cannot hide this under the rug anymore

    The MOD channel is being swarmed with dislikes

    Of course it is, it is part of the western campaign to defeat the Russians... they can't do it on the battlefield so they are doing it on social media and you are just lapping it up you dumb ****.

    Russians are getting ready to get out in the streets

    I am ready, Putin must do something or step down

    **** off.


    I don't know about the others, but I think its normal to be frustrated after seeing how the Ukro Nazis have managed to break through Russian defenses in the Kharkov direction and make significant gains.

    What significant gains? They just lost a shit ton of soldiers for the temporary access to territory that was not held or defended by anyone... and now they will be on the receiving end of artillery and airstrikes till they leave.

    To restate. This is a major defeat

    Yes, because the core of western propaganda is to state some bullshit and then repeat it till you can take no more...

    Putin, shoigu, someone has to step down

    No they don't. And repeating it over and over does not make it true... Biden should step down.

    Trump won that election fair and square.

    So you found 10k fools

    Half probably Ukro psyops trolls, half doomers

    All the IPs are in California...

    Kinda ironic that all the idiots professing to hold the line on the fvcking internet, on an insignificant board, all advocate for others to go to the real front, but not themselves.

    The ones preaching HATO propaganda seem the least interested in putting on a uniform and making a real difference.

    The first and most important thing is to get rid of Putin. In any way possible.

    He is too legalistic, diplomatic (still keeps calling Russian enemies as partners) and cares too much about Russia's international (western) image.

    Those are secondary things when you have a war to fight and to win.

    But Putin is too old to learn new tricks. He is not a wartime leader. Russia will not win this war under Putin.

    One has to ask, why is the solution always to get rid of Putin?

    Doesn't matter what the problem is... the solution is always removing Putin... almost like he knows what he is doing and does not panic and get his panties in a bunch... he is too clever for the west and so they want him gone... that is what this entire conflict is all about... getting rid of Putin...

    Which is why he should stay president.

    Several things need to happen in order for Russia to regain its honor and respect

    Russia already has honour and respect... that is why the entire rest of the world are not putting sanctions on Russia... it is the west that is funding nazis and supporting and concealing war crimes and war criminals, not to mention stealing food meant for the third world and cooking up deadly viruses to kill people with.

    The pool of Ukrainian meat is just too big and they will throw ethnic Russians in the meat grinder too! And Russia will for sure not use nuclear weapons!!! Did they used nuclear weapons during the 2 wars in Chechenya?

    Chechnya is Russian territory... why nuke themselves?

    Western Ukraine is Poland... who gives a **** about radiation there?

    пшек, it's rich you calling pussy, along with fucking Canadians and Pindos

    We are not being your friend letting you act like a pussy... a real friend tells their friend when they are out of line, and supporting a colour revolution in Russia is out of line.

    10,000 sounds like a very round number... a very convenient number... a very suspicious number... clearly a bot farm generated number... a bot farm in the US most likely.

    And how to deliver the FOABs? No strategic aviation is flying over Ukraine due to ukrainian AD systems, only tactical aviation. And Ukrainian Air Force is still alive, 6 months after the start of the special operation.

    Nah, you are right... just nuke the shit hole.

    Well, the Russians should have figured out a different delivery system for FAOBs other than strategic bombers, just like how nukes are delivered using missile platforms.

    Stealth bomber on its way.

    [quote]Just look at the Telegram channel of the Russian Mod. Many Russians are also upset with the current development.


    Man the **** up.

    [quote]But the people who supported Russia must give up EVERYTHING they had...and we are talking about hundreds of thousands of people. Flee or die that's the only choice they have, the second strongest army in the world not able to protect them from Nazis.

    You think if every single damn one of them supported the Russian troops they would leave?

    I think you are exaggerating in your head how many friendlies there could possibly actually be there.

    And at the same time they had a exercise with 50000 soldiers during Vostok? These soldiers could catalyze the complete defeat of Ukraine in only 2-3 months!

    Send in a huge force and the Ukrainian army will put on civilian clothes and get into civilian vehicles and become a guerilla army that moves into Russia with the refugees.

    The trolling here by certain accounts is off the charts, and yours is one of the most insidious ones. Dimwitts obviously can't notice shit.

    Interesting word insidious... but if you really understood its meaning you would be applying it to people who claim to support Russia who want Putin gone because obviously all these years Putin has been holding Russia back by resisting the west and not letting them have their way with Russia and Russians.

    A FOAB is normally too heavy for a conventional rocket compared to nuclear systems. If you are strong enough you can carry a 50 kT warhead easy, a FOAB is over 7 tons.

    Would make an absolutely awesome VIED... put it in an armoured vehicle and drive it by remote control into enemy territory and boom.

    43 years old scientist with military experience (NATO army).

    Congrats... the frontal charge to make the Russians run out of ammo worked a treat, your former employers are god damn geniuses... they are truly shortening this war as we speak.

    My strength is recognizing when I've failed and learning from my mistakes.

    Jumping to conclusions before the full and honest information is in is not how you learn anything except what western propaganda wants you to learn... Putin must go...

    Russian leadership right now......

    No, that is Kievs tactics... Russian forces are just fine... their glowing barrels keeping them warm.

    I wish them the best in the world and hope that the Nazis will kill none of the people that stayed.

    So you wish the nazis will stop being nazis... what were you just saying about learning from mistakes?

    What ist with you armchair general? Wink Why you are not fighting? People who don't care are called nihilists! Very Happy haha

    Are you a nihilist or you simply believe everything the Russian MoD says?

    They don't have a track record of lying so why not believe them. And I am not fighting because I don't need to be there to tell them their tactics are wrong and they are all fucking idiots because I know better than they do because I read stuff on the internet.

    I think they are doing just fine... just the right tactics and good results at a level that is sustainable and affordable.

    You would see footage of it being used. As far as we know no flanker were used above ukraine since that naval su-30 got shot in Odessa few months back.

    So lack of footage means it isn't happening. Are you that stupid.

    In ukraine Su-34 dosn't bomb, doesn't jam and doesn't use AA missiles. Even if it was designed for it, it failed miserably. And for air to air it has a shitty radar with old r-27. Against rafale, typhoon and f-35 it would be just a blind target.

    It actually has a rather good radar and it can use any AAM that the Su-35 can use including the R-37M.

    The morale among Russians is very low right now. Sad to see...

    Interesting they all speak English... is Telegram an English forum?

    Russia can adapt. The level of doom doesn't really make sense to me. If the SMO were to fail, why did it chew through Ukraines best troops for 5 months ? Why didn't it fail in the first month ?

    It is western bots. Infecting the fragile little pussies...

    Your little pay checks will dry up in a few days and we won't see you twats again until the next coordinated Internet offensive.

    Make sure you don't get paid in US dollars or Euros... no one will be accepting that shit soon.


    Both the British and Ukrainians have mentioned the possibility of limited nuclear war. Putin using a tactical nuke is the ultimate kill shot for Western planners.

    He wont use a nuke... he will just kill Zelensky and their Rada and as many of his allies as they can in one or two strikes... preferably with a HATO official or two present.

    The result - complete economic isolation of Russia including from China and the ultimate removal of Putin from power

    If he uses a nuke or kills Zelensky and some western officials he will be more popular than ever at home and in China... the Chinese are sick of you censored  too.

    The cost for readmittance to the "family of nation" - complete demilitarization and the removal of Russian nuclear potential.

    The west promised Russia would be welcomed back in to the international community if they gave up communism and for that they got the 1990s.

    I am sure nuking all of western Ukraine and Europe  would be higher on his list of things to do that to submit to the west.

    No matter how this conflict ends Russia is not getting back to being friends with Europe or the US... they wont forget you funded nazis.

    I understand westerners don't care about nazis... most of them secretly are nazis... especially in the northern areas and the Baltics, but Russians don't like them at all... except the extremely stupid ones that think they are nazis.

    This is what living in alternate realities and consuming propaganda (official and unofficial from your favorite grifter analysts living the life in the west) does to a brain.

    Yeah, that is what all you bots were paid to say today Vann.

    It seems that there was a few hundred of Russkie covering forces there, and that's it.
    Is it a fuckup or a trap, we will see.

    It is a strategy they have been using for months and it pays dividends... lots of orcs are worm food because of it.

    It's a German name. It literally means Walther from Oldenburg. I'm not sure there was ever a Nazi with that name.

    I would say there would be thousands... even today considering the way the west embraces nazis in the Ukraine.

    We agree on that. Ukrainians by luck or planning found a weak spot in defense and whole thing collapsed. I've seen numbers of 900 soldiers guarding Balakleya sector. How the **** that happened and why they didn't call up reinforcements sooner?

    The whole point of the plan is for the Orcs to attack and the forces to fall back while keeping the enemy under fire... sending in extra forces would be stupid... let the artillery and air power attacks thin their numbers first...

    [quote]I ABSOLUTELY guarantee you there is going to be lots and lots of foreign mercernaries coming from ass-hurt post soviet block countries to get involved in this war more than ever now, especially with the ramstein meeting for hohols to get supplied more with weapins.


    Do you promise, because grinding up those censored  will be rather more satisfying than grinding up Orc conscripts.

    [quote]There are two ways that I can think of that must be done to correct this **** up. Step 1 recapture everything the ukrainians gained in ther counter attack. 2. immediately grab a ukrainian city that wasnt claimed before.

    Or they could just keep killing them the way they are now...

    This is the level of horseshit I am seeing from the other side. Apparently mods are okay with letting those retards post here. Nah we dont even know how bad it all is or how blown out of proportion it all is and I will certainly not trust outside shills and anti russian posters to give me the scoop on what is happening.

    I think it is important for the panic mongers to reveal themselves... the usual suspects...

    We will go nowhere by calling everyone who has a different opinion a retard bro.

    We need to call those supporting the nazis nazis because that is what they are doing and claiming that somehow the solution is for Putin to step down seems like a conveniently pro Biden pro EU pro HATO stance to take from people claiming to care about Russia and Russians and also Ukrainian civilians that Nazis are talking about murdering.

    But some of them are driven by either fear or wrongly understanding patriotism.
    It is still an opinion of fellow guy.

    Helping spread propaganda, I think if it was me I would want a bit of a slap to the face if I became defeatist... if you get offended at that well I don't care you don't like being slapped and getting called a pussy when you are acting like a pussy.

    This logic is funny, it doesn't matter how much success you have, all it takes is a few major fucks up to make major costs occur.

    Actually that is an excellent point that bares repeating... the western analogy is throwing the baby out with the bath water... getting rid of everything in a fit of panic or rage or ignorance can end up getting rid of something you really don't want rid of.

    And there is no **** up. The Orcs massed forces and struck Russian lines who fell back like they have been doing this entire conflict and inflicting casualties on the enemy and setting them up for artillery and air attacks strikes... the so called success if you can even call it that is that the Orcs sent so many men the withdrawal by the Russian forces was further than they have had to move back in the past.

    A good analogy is a man in the water with a shark and he has had his hands and feet bitten off already so his response is to force his entire upper torso into the mouth of the shark in the hopes that he will choke it... but even the hard line nazi supporters here know the Russian military is not being stretched... they can withdraw... even if they withdraw a long way where are the Orcs going to get the troops to occupy all these towns and villages and cities and when they start murdering people for helping Russian troops what is going to happen then?

    The fanboys are down playing the loss of Izyum (which was strategic and tactical import to the entire Donbas operation), its sad honestly rather than accept a massive failure was made one that could have been AVOIDED by deploying the correct number of troops and treating this like a REAL dam war.

    The orcs are not going to win, they are losing too many men and weapons and arms from the west can't compensate for that...

    Believe I said time and time again, Russia didn't have enough manpower in the field and this OCCURED exactly because of that.

    That's the difference tho between people who actually fought battles and armchair experts, we know better than the ladder thinks they do.

    The orcs probably lost more men in the last four or five days than the Soviets lost in Afghanistan in the 1980s... what a victory for them... what are they going to use for their next advance... US promises of money?

    Yes its war and mistake happen but this is one mistake that shouldn't have happened with modern day tech

    What mistake? The Russian tactic is to kill nazis and they are killing nazis...

    On the other hand it is not acceptable that Ukrainian planes still fly...the Ukrainians use roads as improvised airfields! video on @milinfolive Telegram channel

    There are thousands of different places they can operate from and probably thousands more places where they are playing with cardboard cutouts of aircraft or blow up models of aircraft.

    It is just easier to wait till the real things get airborne because then you kill the pilot too. (most of the time they are flying very low and very fast with very little time to eject).

    Pretend American soldier for the final trolling finish.

    Ironically he is the least hysterical of those pushing Kiev propaganda and is the most rational.

    In western terms he is a moderate nazi I guess... he will appreciate that joke with his time spent with moderate terrorists in Syria.


    WOW... just got an error message to say my reply was too long... never had that before...

    sepheronx, flamming_python, Big_Gazza, kvs, BliTTzZ, Hole, Broski and like this post

    flamming_python
    flamming_python


    Posts : 9056
    Points : 9118
    Join date : 2012-01-30

    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  flamming_python Sat Sep 10, 2022 9:39 pm

    caveat emptor wrote:
    Whole premise of Donbass offensive was, when Artemovsk- Seversk line is done, to launch a two pronged attack from east and north and spread Ukrainian units. Also cut railway line between Barvenkovo and Kramatorsk or completely take Barvenkovo.

    Did Gerasimov tell you that?
    Or was it Dvornikov who confided his plans to you?

    GarryB, Big_Gazza, kvs, ALAMO, BliTTzZ, Hole, Backman and like this post


    Sponsored content


    Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23 - Page 32 Empty Re: Russian special military operation in Ukraine #23

    Post  Sponsored content


      Current date/time is Sun May 19, 2024 4:03 pm