I agree with you first point, but everything after that.... Creating a new state, especially one that is "anti-Islamic", would only create more division in an already unstable Middle East. It would be déjà vu all over again... Plus, most Kurds are Islamic (Shia at the very least) and probably wouldn't except anything otherwise... Nevermind that the concept of Communism has never properly been enforced on to them. A great idea in practice, a terrible one in the real world.