Russia Defence Forum

Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

Military Forum for Russian and Global Defence Issues


+41
magnumcromagnon
Morpheus Eberhardt
NationalRus
As Sa'iqa
Firebird
ExBeobachter1987
arpakola
d_taddei2
Zivo
dionis
Hannibal Barca
GarryB
Mike E
Asf
Viktor
gregoire
Regular
sepheronx
TR1
Vann7
TheArmenian
kvs
higurashihougi
etaepsilonk
F-15E
Flyingdutchman
Cyberspec
Austin
Big_Gazza
mutantsushi
partizan
zg18
mack8
Petro007
syxthtysyxthsyx
KomissarBojanchev
fragmachine
cracker
Airbornewolf
TheGeorgian
medo
45 posters

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    magnumcromagnon
    magnumcromagnon


    Posts : 8138
    Points : 8273
    Join date : 2013-12-05
    Location : Pindos ave., Pindosville, Pindosylvania, Pindostan

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  magnumcromagnon Wed Nov 26, 2014 9:37 pm

    Regular wrote:
    magnumcromagnon wrote:
    sepheronx wrote:So what is the situation in Mariupol? How come rebels didnt take it?

    Give it some time, more and more Ukrainians will get sick of Porkyshenko's IMF austerity, Mariupol may very well break away given with enough time.
    I doubt that IMF austerity or removal of parasha will change reality that there army in Mariupol. And Ukrainians will only hate Russia more even if they start living in the caves.  hav bad feeling that Donbass will be no better as it's now shelled to glass and I doubt Russia will ditch money on these folks. Yo have to literally rebuild everything again like after ww2. It has nothing to offer to Russia. Fossil fuel?

    Why don't you take a good look how political economies form borders and boundaries of most countries. The United States was nearly brought to its knees and nearly Balkanized from a civil war over a dispute on a political economy based on industrial capital vs slavery capital...a war that had whole families divided fighting on different sides of the war, in that respect very similar to what's happening in Ukraine. The Autogestion the economy of worker self-management was one of the leading factors to why the former Yugoslavia fractured, the IMF austerity that hit Russia led to large parts of the USSR breaking away from Russia, the hyperinflation that hit the Wiemar Republic so hard that extremists like Hitler 'looked good' and it made many Germans willing to re-draw their countries boundaries under his command. There's plenty wars over the last century over countries battling to re-draw boundaries to seize natural resources. The severe IMF/ECB austerity is making many EU countries fracture with growing separatist movements. Scotland wants to secede from Great Britain, Catalonia wants to secede from Spain, Flanders wants to secede from Belgium, Venice wants to secede from Italy. If you don't think a political economy that's spiraling into a black hole won't further fuel militant separatism, then you haven't read enough history books. Let's see how 'patriotic' those officers in the Ukrainian army stationed in Mariupol are when they find out their parents and grand parents are struggling to survive because their pension funds have been sliced in half just to meet IMF conditionalities enforced by their civilian govt.
    Viktor
    Viktor


    Posts : 5796
    Points : 6429
    Join date : 2009-08-25
    Age : 43
    Location : Croatia

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  Viktor Wed Nov 26, 2014 10:07 pm

    Ukraine begun to steal EU gas in its storages Very Happy


    Ukraine has frozen and stole from UGS 2 billion cubic meters. meters of gas
    avatar
    Vann7


    Posts : 5385
    Points : 5485
    Join date : 2012-05-16

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  Vann7 Thu Nov 27, 2014 5:54 am



    Russia have nothing to win by taking mariupol.. means more people to feed. Ukraine only contribution to Russia was
    some spare parts to their missiles and a safe transit zone for their Gas.. but aside of that Russia needs nothing. So economically speaking ,Russia have more to lose than to win by taking more territory. The best thing that can happen
    is either Poroshenko to get rid of the nazis and put them all in jail and make peace with Russia or simply that Ukraine economy collapse and nation disband. But a military solution is not an option.. Thats exactly what USA wants..
    That Russia invades and later create a vietnam against them. With CIA and NATO special forces undercover attacking
    RUssia checkpoints or road side bombs. etc. This is why Russia even does not support the idea of sending Russian peace keepers under UN and Kiev agreement .. because they know the script how it will end.
    arpakola
    arpakola


    Posts : 1510
    Points : 1542
    Join date : 2014-03-12
    Age : 56
    Location : Athens

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty The future of Ukraine in 90 seconds

    Post  arpakola Thu Nov 27, 2014 1:37 pm

    The future of Ukraine in 90 seconds
    Check the sad and, frankly, pathetic footage recently taken at the Ukrainain-Polish border: these poor people are trying to storm the Polish checkpoint every day to try to sell or barter something, or to find a job. This has been happening every day. The saddest thing about that is that this is only a timid beginning for a phenomenon which will inexorably grow. The poor Ukies can sing "Ще не вмерла України" ("The Ukraine has not died yet", the Ukrainian national anthem, itself a bad copy of the Polish one) but it sure looks to me like the Ukraine is dying.
    arpakola
    arpakola


    Posts : 1510
    Points : 1542
    Join date : 2014-03-12
    Age : 56
    Location : Athens

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  arpakola Thu Nov 27, 2014 1:38 pm

    Vann7 wrote:

    Russia have nothing to win by taking mariupol.. means more people to feed. Ukraine only contribution to Russia was
    some spare parts to their missiles and a safe transit zone for their Gas.. but aside of that Russia needs nothing. So economically speaking ,Russia have more to lose than to win by taking more territory. The best thing that can happen
    is either Poroshenko to get rid of the nazis and put them all in jail and make peace with Russia or simply that Ukraine economy collapse and nation disband. But a military solution is not an option..  Thats exactly what USA wants..
    That Russia invades and later create a vietnam against them. With CIA and NATO special forces undercover attacking
    RUssia checkpoints or road side bombs. etc.  This is why Russia even does not support the idea of sending Russian peace keepers under UN and Kiev agreement .. because they know the script how it will end.

    marioupol is an asset
    (also has lots of Greek ethnic)

    =================================
    Donetsk, Novorossia, Nov 27, 2:15 p.m.
    Two civilians are murdered under the UAF shelling - a 12 year old boy and an adult, at least 6 are injured.
    Couple houses are damaged, as well as a hospital. There is a fire in a cottage.
    UPD Three civilians is said are murdered
    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 10432148_1577686089121404_3554360667339909663_n
    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 10382440_1577686102454736_6608312753422180440_n
    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 1509986_1577686095788070_5401761870590529519_n


    magnumcromagnon
    magnumcromagnon


    Posts : 8138
    Points : 8273
    Join date : 2013-12-05
    Location : Pindos ave., Pindosville, Pindosylvania, Pindostan

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  magnumcromagnon Thu Nov 27, 2014 1:52 pm

    As I predicted, Pensioners are getting slammed by the corrupt Porkyshenko govt...the economic blockade on Eastern Ukraine is a convienent excuse for Kiev to freeze the bank accounts of the Eastern Ukrainian population, and later siphon off the money for themselves like the rent-seeking kleptocrats that they are.

    Pensioners storm banks, sue president as economic blockade enforced on E.Ukraine

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 000_par8039342.si

    Kiev is enforcing an economic blockade on eastern Ukraine, where banks are closed and cash machines and credit cards aren’t working. Disrupted social payments to the elderly have become the most acute issue.

    Only a handful of cash machines are still functional in the breakaway parts of the Donetsk and the Lugansk regions, after local banks received an order from Ukraine’s central bank earlier this week to “suspend” operations.

    This follows a controversial decree signed by Ukrainian President Petro Porishenko on November 16 that is now coming into effect. Kiev is cutting economic ties with rebel-held areas by freezing BANK ACCOUNTS and stopping social payments, including pensions.

    READ MORE: Ukraine scraps human rights treaty for rebel areas, cuts services, freezes banks

    “As soon as we regain control [over E. Ukraine], all of the payments will be carried out,” Ukraine’s PM, Arseny Yastenyuk, said on Wednesday. “We would have liked people in the Lugansk and the Donetsk regions to be able to get their payments now, but we can’t send money there, because it gets stolen in banks and in cash delivery vehicles.”

    Those willing to WITHDRAW whatever’s left on their accounts have to spend hours standing in queues. And what’s left is not much.

    “I was getting my pension via Oshchadbank,” a woman from Makeevka told RIA NOVOSTI. “I have 3,000 hryvnas (around $200) left on my account. But I can’t get them. There has been no money in the banking machine for a week already. How am I supposed to live? I don’t even have money for my medicines.”

    The only option left for many in the breakaway areas is to go to nearby towns under Kiev’s control and try to withdraw cash there. Many are trying to reissue their bank accounts in government-held areas, so as not to lose money. Queues at bus stations are huge.

    Some pensioners are complaining they haven’t received their social payments for months.

    “Ukraine says Donbass is a territory of Ukraine. But it came here with tanks and weapons instead of paying us pensions,” Anatoly Visly from the CITY of Donetsk told Russia’s Channel One. “I’m a war veteran and I have not received my pension for three months”.

    A 72 year-old pensioner from Donetsk, Vladimir Steshchenko has decided that complaining over disrupted payments is not enough and is taking the Ukrainian president to court.

    “Our lawsuit has been accepted and registered,” Steschenko’s lawyer, Tatiana Volkova, told the Ukrainski Noviny news agency. “The defendant is Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko, whose decree approved the illegal decision by the National security and Defense Council of Ukraine.”

    Volkova believes there will be more similar lawsuits, as the presidential decree “differentiates between Ukrainians living in different territories,” which is contrary to the country’s constitution.

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 000_par8039344

    The leaders of the self-proclaimed republics of Donetsk and Lugansk have slammed the economic isolation decision, saying it was contrary to the September Minsk peace agreements, brokered  by the OSCE.

    Vladimir Putin reacted to the decree on the economic blockade of eastern Ukraine by saying that the Kiev authorities were “cutting off those territories with their own hands.”

    READ MORE: Putin: Economic blockade of E. Ukraine a ‘big mistake’

    The Russian president compared Kiev’s confrontation with the Donetsk and Lugansk regions to Russia’s own armed conflict in the Chechen Republic, which officially ended five years ago. He said that even at the worst moments, Moscow did not stop paying pensions and other social benefits to the Chechen people.

    Leaders of the self-proclaimed republics of Donetsk and Lugansk have meanwhile LAUNCHED their own social payments.

    “Some of the social payments are done with the help of aid sent over from Russia,” the Donetsk People’s Republic Security Council secretary, Aleksandr Khodakovsky said on Wednesday, according to RIA NOVOSTI.

    Payments to single mothers, large families, orphans, disabled children were launched in November, Khodaskovsky said. Pensions are, he says, high on the agenda, with plans to organize payments within a month.

    http://rt.com/news/209283-banks-cash-east-ukraine/?utm_source=browser&utm_medium=aplication_chrome&utm_campaign=chrome

    sepheronx
    sepheronx


    Posts : 8532
    Points : 8794
    Join date : 2009-08-05
    Age : 34
    Location : Canada

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  sepheronx Thu Nov 27, 2014 3:40 pm

    Oh great. Stupid bohonks in Calgary are crying over holdomor again, saying how we should all remember evil Russia.

    Guess we should remember evil Brits for nearly wiping out a race of people, evil americans for enslaving blacks, evil turks for armenian genocide....

    God, these people are far too much. Only line of defense is holdomor for their racist and stupid viewpoint.
    kvs
    kvs


    Posts : 15130
    Points : 15267
    Join date : 2014-09-11
    Location : Turdope's Kanada

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  kvs Thu Nov 27, 2014 4:12 pm

    sepheronx wrote:Oh great. Stupid bohonks in Calgary are crying over holdomor again, saying how we should all remember evil Russia.

    Guess we should remember evil Brits for nearly wiping out a race of people, evil americans for enslaving blacks, evil turks for armenian genocide....

    God, these people are far too much. Only line of defense is holdomor for their racist and stupid viewpoint.

    These Holodomor blood libelists are the worst sort of scum. The whole of western Ukraine (Rivne, Ivano-Frankivsk, Lviv, etc.) were
    under Polish rule during the 1930s. The forced collectivization famines extended from Soviet Ukraine to Kazakhstan, including the Volga
    region of Russia. The people of the Donbass lived through the Holodomor yet the Nazi-allied vermin from west Ukraine uses the
    famine to beat them over the head with!

    The obscenity is mind numbing. The attempt to paint the forced collectivization famines of the 1930s as some sort of Russian
    genocide of Ukrainians takes the cake for revisionist filth. The Bandera-loving Ukrainians in Canada and the USA like to make
    up stories how Russians either 1) did not starve while Ukrainians did or 2) that the Russians were settled in the Donbas after all
    the original inhabitants died out.

    I have some observations pertaining to point (2) above:

    1) Show me the evidence! I have not seen a single survey of the residents of the Donbas which would verify that they
    are all there from after the famine. Proof by assertion from Banderits originating in Lwow is simply not good enough. I have
    heard people from the Donbas saying how the have family graves they tend to from the 1880s. Also, there are Serb and
    Greek communities there. Clearly these did not settle there during the 1930s and are evidence that the Banderites are
    spewing hate fiction.

    2) The Albanian majority in Kosovo is due to the fact that many of them settled there during WWII and after as Serbs
    were ethnically cleansed from the region. The Albanians were Nazi allies and the SS Skanderberg Division did its share of
    atrocities. After WWII, Tito prevented Serb refugees from returning to Kosovo (in the name of brotherly love
    and ethnic peace, one supposes). NATO has never taken these facts into account, all it cares about is that Albanians
    are a majority in Kosovo. Well, Russians are a majority in Crimea and the Donbas. What is good for NATO is good for Russia
    unless you believe in different standards and laws for everyone.

    kvs
    kvs


    Posts : 15130
    Points : 15267
    Join date : 2014-09-11
    Location : Turdope's Kanada

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  kvs Thu Nov 27, 2014 10:25 pm

    I found this posted elsewhere:

    Rada deputy Tatiana Chernovil calls for genocide of the people of Donabas:

    http://vk.com/video11236758_170822888

    Мы не должны идти за их сценарием. Они специально нас ввязывают в эту борьбу. Что такое победа? Вот что такое победа по вашему мнению? Стать на этих территориях. Знаете, что значит стать на тех территориях и контролировать их? Это устроить там ГЕНОЦИД. Потому что те люди там поддерживают Путина и поддерживают сепаратизм.

    We shouldn’t play along with their scenario. They are specially trying to get us involved in this struggle. What is victory? What do we mean by victory? To be on their territories? You know that means being on their territories and controlling them? And that means implementing GENOCIDE there, because those people there are for Putin and separatism.

    You see, genocide is OK as long as NATO's interests are served. Next time you hear the NATO media screeching about genocide
    recall the above and the total and absolute silence in the case of Ukraine.
    higurashihougi
    higurashihougi


    Posts : 3102
    Points : 3189
    Join date : 2014-08-13
    Location : A small and cutie S-shaped land.

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  higurashihougi Fri Nov 28, 2014 7:45 am

    kvs wrote:You see, genocide is OK as long as NATO's interests are served.   Next time you hear the NATO media screeching about genocide
    recall the above and the total and absolute silence in the case of Ukraine.

    You have already seen the Zionists commited war crimes and genocide against Arabic Palestinians. What do the U.S. say ?
    avatar
    Firebird


    Posts : 1723
    Points : 1753
    Join date : 2011-10-14

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  Firebird Fri Nov 28, 2014 11:44 am

    kvs wrote:
    sepheronx wrote:Oh great. Stupid bohonks in Calgary are crying over holdomor again, saying how we should all remember evil Russia.

    Guess we should remember evil Brits for nearly wiping out a race of people, evil americans for enslaving blacks, evil turks for armenian genocide....

    God, these people are far too much. Only line of defense is holdomor for their racist and stupid viewpoint.

    These Holodomor blood libelists are the worst sort of scum.   The whole of western Ukraine (Rivne, Ivano-Frankivsk, Lviv, etc.) were
    under Polish rule during the 1930s.  
    The forced collectivization famines extended from Soviet Ukraine to Kazakhstan, including the Volga
    region of Russia.  The people of the Donbass lived through the Holodomor yet the Nazi-allied vermin from west Ukraine uses the
    famine to beat them over the head with!

    The obscenity is mind numbing.   The attempt to paint the forced collectivization famines of the 1930s as some sort of Russian
    genocide of Ukrainians takes the cake for revisionist filth.   The Bandera-loving Ukrainians in Canada and the USA like to make
    up stories how Russians either 1) did not starve while Ukrainians did or 2) that the Russians were settled in the Donbas after all
    the original inhabitants died out.

    I have some observations pertaining to point (2) above:

    1) Show me the evidence!  I have not seen a single survey of the residents of the Donbas which would verify that they
    are all there from after the famine.  Proof by assertion from Banderits originating in Lwow is simply not good enough.  I have
    heard people from the Donbas saying how the have family graves they tend to from the 1880s.   Also, there are Serb and
    Greek communities there.   Clearly these did not settle there during the 1930s and are evidence that the Banderites are
    spewing hate fiction.

    2) The Albanian majority in Kosovo is due to the fact that many of them settled there during WWII and after as Serbs
    were ethnically cleansed from the region.  The Albanians were Nazi allies and the SS Skanderberg Division did its share of
    atrocities.   After WWII, Tito prevented Serb refugees from returning to Kosovo (in the name of brotherly love
    and ethnic peace, one supposes).  NATO has never taken these facts into account, all it cares about is that Albanians
    are a majority in Kosovo.  Well, Russians are a majority in Crimea and the Donbas.   What is good for NATO is good for Russia
    unless you believe in different standards and laws for everyone.


    I like to think of myself as reasonably clued up. But thats never really dawned on me.

    My family left Kiev in the Stalin era mainly down to Stalin attempting some Ukrainification, which he later dumped. All part of this " chauvinism of nations" doctrine (because he was Georgian).

    But yes, the W Ukr nutters are all crowing on about this libellous crap of "Holodomor" and yet their forebears weren't even in the Soviet Union at the time!!Most people who starved ie due to famine NOT something deliberate, were actually pro Russian or Russian and living in what is now the East of the Ukr or elsewhere in the USSR.

    This Holodomor garbage I am sure comes from Washington with Canadians who's ancestors were from Lvov etc.
    higurashihougi
    higurashihougi


    Posts : 3102
    Points : 3189
    Join date : 2014-08-13
    Location : A small and cutie S-shaped land.

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  higurashihougi Sat Nov 29, 2014 1:05 pm

    Would like to ask your opinion about this article:

    They are neigiotating. Porkie cannot stop the war at the moment. Because if the war is stopped, people can easily turn their attention to the MH17 crisis, and the criminal deeds of Porkie and Kyiv facist in this event will be exposed.

    Meanwhile, the West is trying to get the industrial area of Donbass.

    And these dogs are tricking each other.

    Porkie want to trick the West into a no-ending war in Ukrainia. Porkie is hoping for the war funds from the West and hopes that he can steal some parts in this fund. However this cannot happen because right inside the Kyiv goverment, there are still independent figures who reject the domination of the West. And Porkie still want a victory to avenge the humiliating defeat of Kyiv forces.

    But he cannot be successful. The reason is that, Russian military level is far superior than the West.

    In Novorossiya, Russia provide information based on radar, AWACS, satellites to the separatists. And Russia use the information to reorganize and check the originally unorganized and divided separatist insurgents. Donbass separatists then make use of Russian advices and info, and then successfully defeat the attacks of Porkie.

    How long the war can be ? Don't really know. But the what we can know for sure is that Porkie can't win. Ukie will suffer more and more, from lack of funds to lack of weapons. But the mad-dogs, war-like scums in Kyiv and in Washington DC will use that reason to demand for more funds, more investment, and the political scum will steal money from these funds for themselves. And the war can go on forever, because the mad-dogs, political scums can eat money forever.

    That is how the U.S. make a war, for the political scums to eat money, and innocent people die. That's why we have Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan.

    The very dangerous thing for the West is the level of competency and veterancy of Novorossian insurgents. One element in that competency is the growth and development of technology. New technologies in fact are very beneficial for the insurgents and guerillas. For example, in the past guerillas needed RPG and cannon to deal with tanks. Now they can have ATGMs, very convenient. Another example, today we can have UAV bombers with can do (some of) the work of B-52 in the past.

    You can see, there are SAM, UAV, ATGM,... which are quite suitable or are specialized for guerillas, and for Novorossiyan insurgents. With the matureness, competency, veterancy and experience of Novorossiyan fighters, they can effectively use them with small modification.

    Imagine the fate of the West, when passive radars become guerilla radars of Muslims in Iraq Syria Afghan. The guerillas can use it to shot down fighters, transporting airplanes, dominate the air... And imagine that these radars walk into the space of New York, Paris... or crazy nerds, crazy university students create the self-made UAVs and use them the bombard the White House ....

    =====

    The West want Russia to take part in the war Ukraina, just like the event of Spain in 1936-39. But the West is wrong.

    You have to know that, the event of WWI and the 1939-1940 period of WWII is that, newborn, new power like Germany and Japan wanted to destroy the old and rotten colonial system of the West in order to gain a bigger share of power, and they made war because of that. The event of WWIII, a war with no killing, no gun firing, is the same thing.

    And in WWIII, the opponent of the old rotten system is not Germany, but China and India. And unlike WWI and WWII, in this WWIII, Russia is in the same side of China and India.

    In this economical world war III, the BRICS is destroying the rotten system of the West. For example, most of Latin America is rejecting the U.S. and is gathering around the leadership of Brazil. The south parts of Africa is following Mandela's country. And China and India... well, ha ha, they are growing with amazing speed while the West is still stagnating.

    That's it. World War III has already begun. But Russia does not need to intervene in anyone. Russia does not need to go into Ukraina. The Trotskists dogs has already run away to Ukie. And in Russia, Stalin looks at that and says "ha ha ha, I win".

    In WWII Germany attacked Russia. But in WWIII, China and India do not attack Russia.

    In 1936, Russia sent troops into Spain. But in 2014, Russia does not need to send troops into Ukraina.

    In 1936, there were dogs of Leon Trosky who were dreaming about an unreal global revolution. As a result, Russia spent an unneccessary and unsuccessful war in Spain. But today, Troskits are gone. Putin does not send troop to Kyiv.

    And Putin has put the facist rotten Kyiv goverment into a war with no escape, no ending. The Kyiv facist cannot end this war, because they want to eat money from the West. And if the war is stopped, people will turn attention to the Mh17 and all the criminal deeds of facist regime in the MH17 will be exposed.

    Meanwhile, The West is crazy about Donbass industrial area.

    That's it. The West want to make Russia intervene into Ukraina. So that the political scumbag in Bavaria and in the West can become the new Hitler. But they fail.

    You have to know that, no matter whether Russia did, Nazi Germany critically had to attack the West. They want to destroy the rotten colonial system of the West so that they can have a greater share of power in the globe.

    But then the political scumbag of Hitler wanted to attack Russia. If Hitler had continued the attack onto England, he would have needed more aircrafts, warships, transporters, tanks. And the political scumbags who lived by simple weapons and machine pisptols would have fallen out of favour. The political scumbags and Hitler told the people that, their machine pistols and simple weapons could destroy Russia. And they attacked Russia. And in 1945 Russia went directly into Hitler's stronghold in Berlin to search for him. And Hitler commited suicide.

    Today. Although our dear Merkel has to live toghether with some political scums from Bavaria and Denmark who eat American shit, but they are the minority.

    Today, the Axis powers are China, Russia, Brazil, South Africa,... and they have Russia on their side, unlike WWI and WWII.

    Therefore Putin does not need to send troops to Ukraina.
    avatar
    As Sa'iqa


    Posts : 398
    Points : 332
    Join date : 2013-06-01
    Age : 29
    Location : Western Poland

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  As Sa'iqa Sat Nov 29, 2014 6:33 pm

    Cassad has just published another BS report about Ukrainian casualties. According to some "Interregional Fund for the Protection of Strategic Security"(I have no clue what it is) - Ukrainian casualties since April up until now are ca. 20,000 dead which includes

    1. 3450 members of the Right Sector
    2. several thousand militiamen from National Guard units
    3. 11 715 members of the Ukrainian Armed Forces, mostly from:
    - 25th Airmobile Brigade
    - 95th Airmobile Brigade
    - 79th Airmobile Brigade
    - 24th Motorized Brigade
    - 51th Mechanized Brigade
    - 72th Mechanized Brigade

    Make a simple calculation - I don't know how strong a typical Ukrainian brigade is but let's assume for the sake of Cassad's argument that it's 4500 men strong (a very large brigade). 4500*6=27000 men - two medium size divisions. If we believe his argumentation, then we are led to believe that almost 1 out of 2 (most casualties were supposedly sustained by these units) soldiers serving in these units was killed. Shocked If we exclude non-combat units then how many fighting men died? 75% Shocked Broken down to daily casualties it would give us about 50 killed/day. Given that for most of April, May and June pretty much nothing took place and 75% of fighting was done from July up to early September, what casualties did they sustain in that period? 100 killed per day? Shocked

    Someone may neg rep me for this but you know... I'm just using my brain to doubt.
    kvs
    kvs


    Posts : 15130
    Points : 15267
    Join date : 2014-09-11
    Location : Turdope's Kanada

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  kvs Sat Nov 29, 2014 7:39 pm

    As Sa'iqa wrote:Cassad has just published another BS report about Ukrainian casualties. According to some "Interregional Fund for the Protection of Strategic Security"(I have no clue what it is) - Ukrainian casualties since April up until now are ca. 20,000 dead which includes

    1. 3450 members of the Right Sector
    2. several thousand militiamen from National Guard units
    3. 11 715 members of the Ukrainian Armed Forces, mostly from:
       - 25th Airmobile Brigade
       - 95th Airmobile Brigade
       - 79th Airmobile Brigade
       - 24th Motorized Brigade
       - 51th Mechanized Brigade
       - 72th Mechanized Brigade

    Make a simple calculation - I don't know how strong a typical Ukrainian brigade is but let's assume for the sake of Cassad's argument that it's 4500 men strong (a very large brigade). 4500*6=27000 men - two medium size divisions. If we believe his argumentation, then we are led to believe that almost 1 out of 2 (most casualties were supposedly sustained by these units) soldiers serving in these units was killed. Shocked If we exclude non-combat units then how many fighting men died? 75% Shocked Broken down to daily casualties it would give us about 50 killed/day. Given that for most of April, May and June pretty much nothing took place and 75% of fighting was done from July up to early September, what casualties did they sustain in that period? 100 killed per day? Shocked

    Someone may neg rep me for this but you know... I'm just using my brain to doubt.

    Your hand waving appeals to "plausibility" is what is truly BS.

    If these casualty estimates had no relation to reality then the Kiev regime would not need to have had several rounds
    of recruitment. The regime started with about 45000 men and today it has managed to increase this number to between
    55 and 60 thousand. Losing 20000 men over half a year in full blown conventional warfare with incompetent military
    command and the use of modern MLRS systems is totally consistent. I note how you do not provide your own estimate.
    From your tone you probably think it is 2000 men or less. Now that would be hilariously implausible.

    We are not dealing with some US air assault on Iraq here. So the regime casualties cannot be expected to be small.
    As proof of the incompetence of the regime forces command take the formation of one cauldron after another until the
    ceasefire. According to regime soldiers they have lost thousands in these cauldrons alone.
    avatar
    As Sa'iqa


    Posts : 398
    Points : 332
    Join date : 2013-06-01
    Age : 29
    Location : Western Poland

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  As Sa'iqa Sat Nov 29, 2014 7:58 pm

    Isn't 50-60k for Donbass only?

    The reason why I doubt this estimate is that it would break pretty much all trends in battlefield lethality evident in industrial/post industrial warfare - both in total number of casualties (a freaking high number for a relatively small army) and in proportion of various casualty types (dead/wounded/missing/captured). If they claimed 20,000 TOTAL casualties (dead, wounded, captured) - it would be a plausible estimation and I would believe them. But they claim 20,000 killed - which not only makes a ridiculously high casualty rate but it would also make the Donbass war the only war in modern history (since roughly 17th century) in which the number of dead exceeds the number of wounded Shocked (several times - unless you believe that the total number of wounded on UKR side is greater than the number of people in all Ukrainian military formations currently active Shocked)

    Hell, even 800,000 strong Iraqi Army lost only about 30,000 dead and 75,000 wounded after one month of the most intensive aerial campaign in history + 4 days of devastating ground campaign... Where is logic in their claims?
    flamming_python
    flamming_python


    Posts : 8988
    Points : 9050
    Join date : 2012-01-30

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  flamming_python Sat Nov 29, 2014 11:48 pm

    Most reasonable estimates of Ukrainian casualties I've heard of pin the number as somewhere around 8000.

    Hard to say if these figures include the 'unofficial' Ukrainian pro-regime combatants or just the ones under the direct command of the Ukr military and interior ministry (police).
    Most of those battalions are technically subordinated to the army, interior ministry, SBU, etc... but tend to act semi-independently, and also there are some private oligarch-sponsored volunteer & mercenary groups and so on that haven't been 'legalized' by Kiev yet. So hell knows.

    Number of rebel casualties is unknown. Wouldn't be surprised if its significantly lower though. They have been outgunned and outnumber all throughout but also they've been doing almost all the defending, encircling & ambushing, not to mention the intense period of fighting shortly before the Minsk agreement when Russia stepped up its assistance and Ukrainian columns started getting annihilated with massive casualties.
    avatar
    Firebird


    Posts : 1723
    Points : 1753
    Join date : 2011-10-14

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  Firebird Sun Nov 30, 2014 12:31 am

    I think the Ukrainian casualties are high.
    Just think of the tragedy of Russia's campaign in the 1st Chechen War.

    The Donbass soldiers were executing a guerilla campaign pretty well. Especially because the Ukr Nazis were morons. And because Donbass could tap into defecting forces and stockpiled items from the Soviet era/other supporting sources.

    Often a figure of 6 casualties for one death is given. That was the case in the US invasion of Iraq (2nd one). But they had fairly good medical support and were fighting a weak enemy. Unlike the junta vs Donbass.

    I'm sure many Nazis/junta soldiers were lost. But many would have been injured, or defected to Donbass or walked across the Russian border etc, or just went missing in action ie refused to fight.

    As for exact figures, maybe the junta "lost" 20k soldiers. But that doesn't mean 20k were killed.
    Just my guesswork.

    Anyway, I hope Donbass, Novorossiya make sure the threat of the junta and whoever is assisting it is smashed to smithereens. Its appalling to think that nearly 70yrs after the Great Patriotic War there are still Nazi vermin with their shit.
    GarryB
    GarryB


    Posts : 38981
    Points : 39477
    Join date : 2010-03-30
    Location : New Zealand

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  GarryB Sun Nov 30, 2014 12:49 am

    Hell, even 800,000 strong Iraqi Army lost only about 30,000 dead and 75,000 wounded after one month of the most intensive aerial campaign in history + 4 days of devastating ground campaign... Where is logic in their claims?

    The Iraqi Army was a reasonably trained army that surrendered fairly quickly.

    The Ukrainian army was in a pathetic state and was supplimented in numbers with idiots wanting to go and kill some people but likely with little real training to do so... in other words lots of cannon fodder.

    In many ways Chechnia for the Ukraine.
    avatar
    Vann7


    Posts : 5385
    Points : 5485
    Join date : 2012-05-16

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  Vann7 Sun Nov 30, 2014 1:46 am

    As Sa'iqa wrote:Isn't 50-60k for Donbass only?

    The reason why I doubt this estimate is that it would break pretty much all trends in battlefield lethality evident in industrial/post industrial warfare - both in total number of casualties (a freaking high number for a relatively small army) and in proportion of various casualty types (dead/wounded/missing/captured). If they claimed 20,000 TOTAL casualties (dead, wounded, captured) - it would be a plausible estimation and I would believe them. But they claim 20,000 killed - which not only makes a ridiculously high casualty rate but it would also make the Donbass war the only war in modern history (since roughly 17th century) in which the number of dead exceeds the number of wounded Shocked (several times - unless you believe that the total number of wounded on UKR side is greater than the number of people in all Ukrainian military formations currently active Shocked)

    Hell, even 800,000 strong Iraqi Army lost only about 30,000 dead and 75,000 wounded after one month of the most intensive aerial campaign in history + 4 days of devastating ground campaign... Where is logic in their claims?

    I have no idea of the numbers... but there IS [ first hand evidence from the ukraine army leaders that kiev is artificially minimizing the casualties and losses of their side... i saw a video.. (i think it was the ukie with a funny big head) that was saying that when the defense minister claim that 15 soldiers died.. that in reality was 150. and there is another video where Ukie army was discussing how they were being trashed by "the Russian army" as they call the Rebels. That they lost 3 major brigades units with about 4500 to 10,000 losses.. (not sure of what they mean..) and that was in about few weeks.. when the cauldrons captured /encircle about 8,000 ukie soldiers..
    So make no mistake the casualties of the ukie army are huge..



    That video was uploaded before the Rebels began a major offensive where they advanced in all fronts and on the offensive towards mariupol.. so after that video it got worse for the ukie army. So if i were to guess.. the losses of ukie army have to be in the 10,000 at least! and as high as 20,000. That does not include wounded people.. that should be 10,000+. What Pro Russian sources were saying is that Ukies casualties/killed/wounded combined were in the 30,000+ and theirs in the 5,000.
    Regular
    Regular


    Posts : 3868
    Points : 3842
    Join date : 2013-03-10
    Location : Ukrolovestan

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  Regular Sun Nov 30, 2014 4:30 am

    Well I hate guessing, but it's defiantly bigger number than Ukrainian reports say, but it's not as bad as pro sep sources say too. Somewhere in the middle. Let god sort it out.
    magnumcromagnon
    magnumcromagnon


    Posts : 8138
    Points : 8273
    Join date : 2013-12-05
    Location : Pindos ave., Pindosville, Pindosylvania, Pindostan

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  magnumcromagnon Sun Nov 30, 2014 5:01 am

    Just some humor... Very Happy

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 0f26b


    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Ba9e0
    TR1
    TR1


    Posts : 5435
    Points : 5433
    Join date : 2011-12-06

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  TR1 Sun Nov 30, 2014 5:35 am

    Cossad just shills anything pro-rebel he can get his hands on.

    3500 right sector dead?

    Rofl. Does right sector even have 1/2 that number of armed troops in the Donbass?
    avatar
    etaepsilonk


    Posts : 707
    Points : 687
    Join date : 2013-11-19

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  etaepsilonk Sun Nov 30, 2014 8:32 am

    flamming_python wrote:Most reasonable estimates of Ukrainian casualties I've heard of pin the number as somewhere around 8000.

    "Opposition block" says 14000.
    All those numbers are just guesstimates anyway. But we can look at the number of reported battle losses to get the idea of the lowest estimate:

    1000 in slaviansk, according to steshin;
    About 2000 near lugansk;
    10000 in border cauldron (three brigades, plus some battalions practically wiped out);
    Several thousand in ilovaisk;
    Several thousand in shahtersk;
    Maybe up to 1000 in amvrosijevka;
    And so on.

    All in all 20000+ dead is entirely possible.

    Another thing is the extreme importance of entrenchment positions for protection. I think some study about iraqi army in gulf war revealed that lack of these measures can increase your casualties exponentially, due to effectiveness of modern artillery (and aviation).
    As a result, UA army sitting in stacked bases under grad fire certainly doesn't help to reduce their losses.


    Not to mention the astonishing use of friggin' mobile phones, lighting up like a christmas tree in display of the nearest ELINT device.
    Werewolf
    Werewolf


    Posts : 5915
    Points : 6104
    Join date : 2012-10-24

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  Werewolf Sun Nov 30, 2014 9:36 am

    I don't know why some people are acting "Suprised" about the inflated and diminished numbers of casualities, both have to keep some Propaganda running to keep Moral at some level or inflate their achievements to boost their moral and gain more volunteers.

    Fact is that the casualties on ukr army side range from 2-8 times higher than what they claim, how much won't come out for long period of time, especially casualties among foreigners (mercenaries/NATO) are kept secret, because "there are no" officialy, it is a struggle of small "innocent and poor country" against a "violent empire".
    Regular
    Regular


    Posts : 3868
    Points : 3842
    Join date : 2013-03-10
    Location : Ukrolovestan

    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  Regular Sun Nov 30, 2014 11:40 am

    So what do You all think about infighting between LNR separatists and Cossacks? Prapor and Shakhter are dead along many other men. Mozgovoi could be next as he was threatened before.
    Makes me think that LNR is same as Ukrainian gov. It shows us that Russia doesn't have full control over them and in peace time without Russian pressure seps will kill themselves. Meh DNR and LNR are junta by themselves now.
    Antimaidan Donetsk members want to ask Strelkov back begging on their knees and say after he left things got much worse . Listen what they think about current situation.

    Sponsored content


    The Situation in the Ukraine. #9 - Page 35 Empty Re: The Situation in the Ukraine. #9

    Post  Sponsored content


      Current date/time is Sat Apr 27, 2024 2:49 am