http://novorossia.today/netherland-confirmed-that-ukraine-had-acting-buk-systems-that-the-tragedy-with-boeing-mh17-in-donbass/
+15
Tsavo Lion
George1
Aristonicus
Mindstorm
Walther von Oldenburg
Neutrality
auslander
PapaDragon
flamming_python
wilhelm
Werewolf
sepheronx
higurashihougi
JohninMK
Khepesh
19 posters
MH-17 downing: Data and update
Walther von Oldenburg- Posts : 1421
Points : 1522
Join date : 2015-01-23
Age : 32
Location : Oldenburg
- Post n°26
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
Netherlands confirmed that only Ukraine had operating Buk systems that caused the tragedy with Boeing MH17 in Donbass
http://novorossia.today/netherland-confirmed-that-ukraine-had-acting-buk-systems-that-the-tragedy-with-boeing-mh17-in-donbass/
http://novorossia.today/netherland-confirmed-that-ukraine-had-acting-buk-systems-that-the-tragedy-with-boeing-mh17-in-donbass/
higurashihougi- Posts : 2667
Points : 2756
Join date : 2014-08-13
Location : A small and cutie S-shaped land.
- Post n°27
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
Walther von Oldenburg wrote:Netherlands confirmed that only Ukraine had operating Buk systems that caused the tragedy with Boeing MH17 in Donbass
http://novorossia.today/netherland-confirmed-that-ukraine-had-acting-buk-systems-that-the-tragedy-with-boeing-mh17-in-donbass/
Another very good news for the new year, if this article is 100% accurate.
Now with such developments, if the E.U. and the White House don't want to carry out a war crime court against Maidan, then I believe even Satan does not want to house them.
Neutrality- Posts : 888
Points : 906
Join date : 2015-05-02
- Post n°28
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
Walther von Oldenburg wrote:Netherlands confirmed that only Ukraine had operating Buk systems that caused the tragedy with Boeing MH17 in Donbass
http://novorossia.today/netherland-confirmed-that-ukraine-had-acting-buk-systems-that-the-tragedy-with-boeing-mh17-in-donbass/
I just finished reading the report and the Dutch committee is pretty straightforward. I'll quote and translate the part in which they specifically talk about the separatists:
-Based on the data from both the AIVD and MIVD we conclude that the pro-Russian separatists had no military capabilities and the intention to shoot down civilian airliners.
The only logical thing they can do right now is to force the Ukrainians to release ALL the remaining data prior to the catastrophe. Or they should knock on Kerry's door because I remember quite clearly him talking about the precise launch site, flight path and time of impact.
JohninMK- Posts : 12289
Points : 12424
Join date : 2015-06-16
Location : England
- Post n°29
MH-17 crash
The MH-17 saga seems to be spluttering into life again. This is an interesting para from the letter from Moscow to the dependants demanding answers. Much more at link.
At the same time, Russia has repeatedly pointed out that the Dutch technical investigation was performed in an extremely nontransparent and biased manner. We support you in your efforts to get answers to the numerous questions that remain unanswered. The Dutch Safety Board should explain to you and to the whole world why the technical investigation took such a long time and why it resulted in some very abstract and vague statements. The Dutch authorities should explain why they distorted facts and concealed data, and why they ignored important data provided by Russia. The DSB should explain why its final report distorted data about missile fragments and places where they were found, why it failed to thoroughly examine penetration holes on the aircraft, why it mismanaged the aircraft debris, why it misrepresented the probable location from which the missile was launched, and many other discrepancies in the final report.
http://www.fort-russ.com/2016/02/federal-air-transport-agency-responds.html
At the same time, Russia has repeatedly pointed out that the Dutch technical investigation was performed in an extremely nontransparent and biased manner. We support you in your efforts to get answers to the numerous questions that remain unanswered. The Dutch Safety Board should explain to you and to the whole world why the technical investigation took such a long time and why it resulted in some very abstract and vague statements. The Dutch authorities should explain why they distorted facts and concealed data, and why they ignored important data provided by Russia. The DSB should explain why its final report distorted data about missile fragments and places where they were found, why it failed to thoroughly examine penetration holes on the aircraft, why it mismanaged the aircraft debris, why it misrepresented the probable location from which the missile was launched, and many other discrepancies in the final report.
http://www.fort-russ.com/2016/02/federal-air-transport-agency-responds.html
Mindstorm- Posts : 1135
Points : 1302
Join date : 2011-07-20
- Post n°30
MH-17 downing : data and update
Interview with Vice President of the society of independent accident investigators Dr. Омаров Захар Галимжанович
http://vpk.name/news/149630_reis_mn17_v_cnii_vvs_minoboronyi_rossii_oprovergnutyi_vyivodyi_gollandskoi_komissii.html
for the magazine "Авиапанорама" (or a not related note : for any interested is present an article on the result of high grade engagement simulation, starting at different altitude, between Su-35 and Rafale

http://aviapanorama.ru/
In the internview are highlited the results coming from simulations employing the normal, internationally accepted, procedures and protocols, for this kind of investigation, that deeply differ from those presented by Duch-lead one ,characterized by very suspect oddities, when not open infractions (like in the case of misterious warhead fragments appearing from nothing at the presentation of the results).
From rigourous data processing appear that the warhead downig the Mh-17 was almost certainly that of an air-to air missile with a mass half that of a Buk missile not of russian production.
Aristonicus- Posts : 18
Points : 20
Join date : 2015-05-01
- Post n°31
MH-17 Downing: data and update
John Helmer's Latest:
Full: http://johnhelmer.net/?p=15188#more-15188
Dutch government prosecutors investigating the downing of Malaysian Airlines Flight MH17 have reported that secret US satellite intelligence they have been shown cannot be used in evidence in a prosecution in an international or Dutch court, and that no evidence is currently available to charge anyone for the crime of firing on the aircraft, killing the 298 passengers and crew on board. The report, in the form of a 5-page letter addressed to families of the victims was signed by Fred Westerbeke, the Dutch official in charge of the investigation, and mailed last week.
Yesterday the Australian government, whose federal police are participating with the Dutch in the criminal investigation, dissociated itself from the contents and conclusions of the Dutch government letter, despite the claim on the signature line by Westerbeke that he was reporting “on behalf of the Joint Investigation Team [comprising] Australia, Belgium, Malaysia, Ukraine and Netherlands”.
Westerbeke has told the selected recipients of his report there is “no video or film footage available from launch or trajectory of the missile”. He implies the investigators have now concluded that widely published photographs of the launch and the missile contrail in the sky are unreliable or false.
Full: http://johnhelmer.net/?p=15188#more-15188
Aristonicus- Posts : 18
Points : 20
Join date : 2015-05-01
- Post n°32
MH-17 Downing: data and update
RE: The Australian Federal Police & MH-17
http://johnhelmer.net/?p=14322
AFP lead investigator Donoghoe, in AFP film clip, contradicts Australian Government on crash site, Ukraine conflict.
Source: http://media.smh.com.au/video-news/video-world-news/afp-forensics-team-at-work-in-the-hague-6892745.html
In their presentation of what they saw, did, and have concluded, the AFP officers are now saying they have no evidence the Novorussians at the crash scene either claimed responsibility for the shoot-down; or acted improperly to withhold or manipulate the crash scene evidence; or stole the victims’ belongings. The AFP is also expressing its “irritation” at public claims of the cause of the crash and the conduct of the Novorussians by the Australian Prime Minister at the time, Tony Abbott. In their presentation to the media, the Australian officers “go out of their way to acknowledge and to defend the humanity of the Ukrainian rebels who were accused of bringing down the aircraft.”
http://johnhelmer.net/?p=14322
Aristonicus- Posts : 18
Points : 20
Join date : 2015-05-01
- Post n°33
MH-17 Downing: data and update
Something from western media!
http://www.express.co.uk/news/world/663787/Ukrainian-fighter-jet-shot-Russian-crash-MH17-BBC-documentary
http://www.express.co.uk/news/world/663787/Ukrainian-fighter-jet-shot-Russian-crash-MH17-BBC-documentary
SHOCK CLAIM: Ukrainian fighter jet shot down Malaysia Airlines' MH17
A BBC documentary will air “shocking new allegations” about the downing of Malaysia Airlines plane MH17, including claims it was shot down by a fighter jet and not a ground-to-air missile.
By DAVID STEPHENSON
PUBLISHED: 00:01, Sun, Apr 24, 2016 | UPDATED: 13:54, Sun, Apr 24, 2016
The Boeing 777 exploded over eastern Ukraine on July 17, 2014, killing 298 people.
The official report concluded that the jet, bound for Kuala Lumpur, was downed by a Russian-made Buk missile fired from a Ukraine area under the control of Russian-backed rebels.
However, the programme will present new evidence that a Ukrainian fighter jet may have shot down the aircraft.
Another theory is that a CIA-backed “terrorist operation” planted two bombs on the airliner.
Witnesses directly beneath the exploding aircraft report seeing at least one fighter jet.
Natasha Beronina said: “It was summer, harvest time. We heard a bang. At first we saw black smoke and two planes, little ones like silver toys. One flew straight on and the other one turned round when the bang happened and flew back from where it had come.”
German investigative journalist Billy Six interviewed 100 witnesses, seven of whom said they saw a fighter jet.Six said: “One of them even told me how he saw it launch a missile. It was like a small line in the sky going into the clouds. Then he heard the big boom.”
He believes two jets shot it down – one firing a canon from the back into the cockpit to destroy the crew.
Then another fired an air-to-air missile. In the intense propaganda war between Ukraine and Moscow, Russia media reported the name of a pilot they believed was responsible, Captain Vladislav Voloshin, based at a southern Ukraine airfield. In an interview, he denied the allegations made by a mechanic on the base.
He said: “We did not carry out flights on July 17. The mechanic also says that three aircraft went out on a mission and I was the only one to return. But again this actually happened on the 23rd.
“He said that the aircraft was carrying air-to-air missiles. There were no air-to-air missiles. I was carrying air-to-surface weapons for ground targets.”
The most shocking allegations come from private investigator Sergey Sokolov. He deployed more than 100 of his agents to investigate the site and examine evidence.
He said they found no shrapnel from a Buk missile. Sokolov said he was “sold” a phone intercept between two CIA agents that suggests they masterminded the planting two bombs on MH-17.
The CIA, he claimed, was helped by the Ukrainian secret service. Sokolov said: “The driving force of the operation were CIA agents and the Dutch security service also had a part to play as the bombs were put on the plane in Holland and this couldn’t have been done anywhere else.”
He added “This terrorist act was a pretext for firstly intensifying sanctions on Russia, secondly to show the world that Russia is a barbarian country and thirdly to strengthen the presence of Nato in Europe, particularly Ukraine.”
However, the documentary tells how British investigative blogging site, Bellingcat, supports the official version that a Buk missile was fi red at the aircraft by Russian-backed rebels.
Conspiracy Files: Who Shot Down MH17?, written and produced by Mike Rudin, BBC Two, May 3, 9pm.
George1- Posts : 17915
Points : 18420
Join date : 2011-12-22
Location : Greece
- Post n°34
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
New Satellite Image Shows Buk System Position During MH17 Crash in Ukraine
Read more: http://sputniknews.com/military/20160514/1039594282/mh17-crash-satellite-images.html#ixzz48cdol9d4
Read more: http://sputniknews.com/military/20160514/1039594282/mh17-crash-satellite-images.html#ixzz48cdol9d4
George1- Posts : 17915
Points : 18420
Join date : 2011-12-22
Location : Greece
- Post n°35
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
Russian Investigation Committee to hand over Almaz-Antei’s info on MH17 crash
More:
http://tass.com/world/901542
More:
http://tass.com/world/901542
George1- Posts : 17915
Points : 18420
Join date : 2011-12-22
Location : Greece
- Post n°36
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
No Russian air defense missile systems crossed Russia-Ukraine border — top brass
Russia’s Defense Ministry comments on the MH17 crash report
MOSCOW, May 24. /TASS/. None of the Russian Army’s air defense missile systems ever crossed the border between Russia and Ukraine, Russia’s Defense Ministry said on Thursday, commenting on the findings released by the Joint Investigation Team on the MH17 crash in Donbass in 2014.
"We got acquainted with the statements made at today’s press conference by representatives of the international investigation team on probing the crash of the Malaysian MH17 Boeing over Ukraine on July 17, 2014," the defense ministry stated.
Russia’s Defense Ministry rejected both in the first hours after the tragedy and subsequently the Ukrainian side’s insinuations on the alleged involvement of Russian servicemen in the air crash over Ukraine and delivered the corresponding evidence to the Dutch investigative team," the ministry said.
"None of the Russian Army’s air defense missile systems ever crossed the Russia-Ukraine border," the ministry said.
"Within the framework of interaction with the Dutch law-enforcement bodies, the Russian side presented overwhelming evidence confirmed by full-scale tests and clearly pointing to the complicity of precisely Ukrainian crews of Buk missile systems in destroying the Boeing airliner from the Netherlands over Ukraine," Russia’s Defense Ministry stressed.
"Moreover, Russia provided the international investigative team with all the continuous primary (unprocessed) data from the Utyos-T air route radar station that was in operation on July 17, 2014 and was located near the community of Ust-Donetsky in the Rostov Region. This radar did not spot any air objects approaching the Boeing airliner from the eastern side, including from the settlement of Snezhnoye or Pervomaiskoye," the ministry said.
Russia’s Defense Ministry expressed its concern that "the Dutch investigation is focused on substantiating its conclusions by using only images from social networks that were skillfully edited by computer graphic aids."
"Moreover, a part of images used during the briefing and prepared by Ukraine’s special services had been earlier demonstrated more than once by the pseudo-investigators from Bellingcat," the defense ministry said.
"These fakes were disavowed and rejected by Russian experts," the ministry added.
Russia’s Defense Ministry drew special attention to the fact that "the Dutch investigators absolutely fail to take into account and have rejected the evidences of eye-witnesses from Ukrainian settlements located close to the crash area testifying to the missile’s launch from the territory controlled by the Ukrainian armed forces."
"Numerous witnesses of the tragedy over Ukraine are not depersonalized images from social networks but are concrete people who made their statements for being recorded, including statements for representatives of European and American media," the ministry said.
"If the international investigative team is really interested in establishing the true culprits of the MH17 crash over Ukraine, its representatives should rely in their statements primarily on facts and eye-witnesses’ evidence and not on falsifications of fake news generators from Bellingcat or the Ukrainian Security Council (SBU)," Russia’s Defense Ministry stated.
Moscow presented overwhelming evidence proving the use of Ukrainian Buk missile systems in downing flight MH17, the ministry said.
"While cooperating with Dutch law enforcement agencies, Russia presented overwhelming evidence proving that Ukrainian Buk missile systems had been used to down the flight en-route from the Netherlands," the statement reads.
"Moreover, all the primary data received by the Utyos-T radar station, which was operating in the [Russian] Rostov region on July 17, 2014, was passed to the international investigative group," the defense ministry added. "The radar station did not record any aerial objects approaching the Boeing from the east, particularly from the direction of the Snezhnoye and Pervomaiskoye settlements," the statement says.
"The Dutch investigation’s determination to justify its conclusions by using only graphically photos posted on social media causes concern," the statement reads.
"The most important thing that we would like to draw attention to is that Dutch investigators rejected testimonies from eyewitnesses living in Ukrainian settlements close to the crash site, which mention a missile launch from an area controlled by the Ukrainian armed forces," the Russian Defense Ministry added.
More:
http://tass.com/defense/1006070
George1- Posts : 17915
Points : 18420
Join date : 2011-12-22
Location : Greece
- Post n°37
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
Russia’s Defense Ministry handed over all data on MH17 crash to Dutch side
A Boeing-777 passenger plane operated by Malaysian Airlines crashed on July 17, 2014
MOSCOW, September 17. /TASS/. Russia’s defense ministry has handed over all the data it has related the MH17 crash in Ukraine to the Dutch side, Igor Konashenkov, the ministry’s spokesman, said on Monday.
"All the documents have been handed over to the Dutch side… We would like the Joint Investigation Team to pay attention to these data and use them in its work," he said.
A Boeing-777 passenger plane operated by Malaysian Airlines crashed on July 17, 2014, en route from Amsterdam to Kuala Lumpur in the east of the Donetsk region. As many as 283 passengers and 15 crew members - citizens of 10 states, were killed in the crash. Despite combat operation on the ground, Kiev opted not to close airspace for international passenger aircraft over the area. The Joint Investigation Team (JIT) includes representatives of the Netherlands, Australia, Belgium, Malaysia and Ukraine. On May 24, it issued an interim report saying that the missile system used to down MH17 originated from the 53rd Anti-Aircraft Missile brigade, a Russian army unit based near Kursk.
Russia’s Defense Ministry rejected all the allegations, saying not a single missile system of the Russian army had ever crossed the Russian-Ukrainian border.
More:
http://tass.com/defense/1021873
A Boeing-777 passenger plane operated by Malaysian Airlines crashed on July 17, 2014
MOSCOW, September 17. /TASS/. Russia’s defense ministry has handed over all the data it has related the MH17 crash in Ukraine to the Dutch side, Igor Konashenkov, the ministry’s spokesman, said on Monday.
"All the documents have been handed over to the Dutch side… We would like the Joint Investigation Team to pay attention to these data and use them in its work," he said.
A Boeing-777 passenger plane operated by Malaysian Airlines crashed on July 17, 2014, en route from Amsterdam to Kuala Lumpur in the east of the Donetsk region. As many as 283 passengers and 15 crew members - citizens of 10 states, were killed in the crash. Despite combat operation on the ground, Kiev opted not to close airspace for international passenger aircraft over the area. The Joint Investigation Team (JIT) includes representatives of the Netherlands, Australia, Belgium, Malaysia and Ukraine. On May 24, it issued an interim report saying that the missile system used to down MH17 originated from the 53rd Anti-Aircraft Missile brigade, a Russian army unit based near Kursk.
Russia’s Defense Ministry rejected all the allegations, saying not a single missile system of the Russian army had ever crossed the Russian-Ukrainian border.
More:
http://tass.com/defense/1021873
Tsavo Lion- Posts : 5780
Points : 5762
Join date : 2016-08-15
Location : AZ, USA
- Post n°38
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
More details: https://news.google.com/articles/CAIiEM3KzHBg-chucIpjfIm9GHQqFwgEKg8IACoHCAownbXoATDh9REwmt8j?hl=ru&gl=RU&ceid=RU%3Aru
https://riafan.ru/1100299-minoborony-rf-obyasnilo-chto-udalos-uznat-po-nomeru-rakety-sbivshei-mh17
Ukraine shot it down by mistake & then decided to lay blame for it on the RF to avoid admitting her guilt & harming Russian- West relations. Russia reveals the MH17 ‘smoking gun’
But why didn't Dutch reveal the picture with that # earlier?
https://www.mk.ru/politics/2018/09/17/ekspert-zayavil-o-sokrytii-vazhnogo-fragmenta-sbivshey-malayziyskiy-boing-rakety.html?from=article_ntrstng
https://riafan.ru/1100299-minoborony-rf-obyasnilo-chto-udalos-uznat-po-nomeru-rakety-sbivshei-mh17
Ukraine shot it down by mistake & then decided to lay blame for it on the RF to avoid admitting her guilt & harming Russian- West relations. Russia reveals the MH17 ‘smoking gun’
But why didn't Dutch reveal the picture with that # earlier?
https://www.mk.ru/politics/2018/09/17/ekspert-zayavil-o-sokrytii-vazhnogo-fragmenta-sbivshey-malayziyskiy-boing-rakety.html?from=article_ntrstng
Last edited by Tsavo Lion on Tue Sep 18, 2018 10:58 pm; edited 5 times in total (Reason for editing : add link, text)
kvs- Posts : 13988
Points : 14133
Join date : 2014-09-11
Location : Turdope's Kanada
- Post n°39
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
Nice reply to some US "journalist" troll.
So Russia was being accused of downing MH-17 before it actually fell from the sky.
NATO = 1984 style toilet.
kvs- Posts : 13988
Points : 14133
Join date : 2014-09-11
Location : Turdope's Kanada
- Post n°40
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
Hilarious Orwellian BoobTube censors the video. Can't have any facts leading to cognitive dissonance can we now...
PhSt- Posts : 916
Points : 922
Join date : 2019-04-02
- Post n°41
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
kvs wrote:Hilarious Orwellian BoobTube censors the video. Can't have any facts leading to cognitive dissonance can we now...
This is why I am advocating for Russia to set up an powerful Youtube counterpart/ alternative. Rutube.ru would be a solid platform, its been around almost the same time as Youtube, but is seems to be underfunded and so it needs some attention and investment from Rus government to prop it up and make it competitive.
GarryB- Posts : 35768
Points : 36294
Join date : 2010-03-30
Location : New Zealand
- Post n°42
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
Its main problem is that most of the videos are in Russian... I am used to watching their programmes about weapons in Russian and not understanding a word and just enjoying the video footage of their hardware... but then again most American programmes about their military weapons are best enjoyed with the sound or at least narration off too.
kvs- Posts : 13988
Points : 14133
Join date : 2014-09-11
Location : Turdope's Kanada
- Post n°43
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
GarryB wrote:Its main problem is that most of the videos are in Russian... I am used to watching their programmes about weapons in Russian and not understanding a word and just enjoying the video footage of their hardware... but then again most American programmes about their military weapons are best enjoyed with the sound or at least narration off too.
This video was in English since the Russian diplomat was at some western conference. His English was good too.
Youtube owned by Google is just purging all inconvenient information. This is 1984 in action but without some state apparatus doing it.
People have in indoctrinated to think that only states can run totalitarian dictatorships. They are sadly mistaken.
magnumcromagnon- Posts : 8158
Points : 8303
Join date : 2013-12-05
Location : Pindos ave., Pindosville, Pindosylvania, Pindostan
- Post n°44
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
kvs wrote:GarryB wrote:Its main problem is that most of the videos are in Russian... I am used to watching their programmes about weapons in Russian and not understanding a word and just enjoying the video footage of their hardware... but then again most American programmes about their military weapons are best enjoyed with the sound or at least narration off too.
This video was in English since the Russian diplomat was at some western conference. His English was good too.
Youtube owned by Google is just purging all inconvenient information. This is 1984 in action but without some state apparatus doing it.
People have in indoctrinated to think that only states can run totalitarian dictatorships. They are sadly mistaken.
Take for an example the banana republics of Latin America; they were controlled by US produce companies like Chiquita (United Fruit co.) which had it's own mercenary army and waged war, arms trafficked weapons, and kidnapped and tortured/killed labor activists. All this dark information came out in court, and the lawyer for Chiquita who defended them was hired in the 'Hope & Change' Obama admin.
Tsavo Lion- Posts : 5780
Points : 5762
Join date : 2016-08-15
Location : AZ, USA
- Post n°45
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
Oddities in versions of the death of the Malaysian liner
JohninMK- Posts : 12289
Points : 12424
Join date : 2015-06-16
Location : England
- Post n°46
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
New investigative documentary by Ukrainian defector
via https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/ukranian-whistleblower-reveals-mh-17-tragedy-was-orchestrated-poroshenko-and-british
via https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/ukranian-whistleblower-reveals-mh-17-tragedy-was-orchestrated-poroshenko-and-british
JohninMK- Posts : 12289
Points : 12424
Join date : 2015-06-16
Location : England
- Post n°47
Re: MH-17 downing: Data and update
http://johnhelmer.org/mh17-court-applies-dutch-law-of-finger-pointing-guilt-by-association-if-the-perpetrator-is-russian-innocence-by-association-if-prosecutor-is-dutch-or-ukrainian/
Tony
@Cyberspec1
·
Nov 18
Interesting comment regarding the Kangaroo trial in Holand
"Its particularly noteworthy that the guilty verdict was passed only to those who were not represented by lawyers.
The court could not refute the arguments of O. Pulatov's defense and was forced to acquit him"
Tony
@Cyberspec1
·
Nov 18
Interesting comment regarding the Kangaroo trial in Holand
"Its particularly noteworthy that the guilty verdict was passed only to those who were not represented by lawyers.
The court could not refute the arguments of O. Pulatov's defense and was forced to acquit him"
GarryB likes this post
|
|