Military Forum for Russian and Global Defence Issues


    BMP-1/BMP-2 Upgrades and Variants

    Share
    avatar
    SeigSoloyvov

    Posts : 442
    Points : 446
    Join date : 2016-04-08

    Re: BMP-1/BMP-2 Upgrades and Variants

    Post  SeigSoloyvov on Mon Apr 17, 2017 9:47 pm

    PapaDragon wrote:
    SeigSoloyvov wrote:If they decide to upgrade mass amounts of BMP-2's that would mean other vehicles are far more behind than planned otherwise there is zero reason to put money into such a project if things like the Kurg are just around the corner.


    This would be geared towards exports. Lots of these things are in use around the world so it is a decent sized market. And does not look all that expensive. Remember, brand new 1000+ hp engine for T-72 costs in the ballpark of just 100.000$ so this kit is probably peanuts as well.

    Also, these vehicles will be going into reserve soon and it is always wise to keep your reserve up to date as much as possible.

    This logic makes sense if Russia already had all the Kurgs etc they wanted. If this was just to update some naval forces or back water reserve garrison units that use maybe a couple hundred BMP-2's that would be an understandable move. To upgrade thousands of them for domestic units doesn't.

    They don't they will not spend tons of money upgrading BMP-2's when they still have to buy tons of new vehicles to replace said BMP-2's.

    Export is another story but domestic? no way. Russian Mod would have to be pretty foolish to do this, not like they have unlimited money even my country who spends way more than them would have an issue with such a concept.
    avatar
    franco

    Posts : 2287
    Points : 2325
    Join date : 2010-08-18

    Re: BMP-1/BMP-2 Upgrades and Variants

    Post  franco on Mon Apr 17, 2017 11:07 pm

    SeigSoloyvov wrote:If they decide to upgrade mass amounts of BMP-2's that would mean other vehicles are far more behind than planned otherwise there is zero reason to put money into such a project if things like the Kurg are just around the corner.


    So far ~400 were upgraded with another 580 in the second order for about ~1000. All mechanical and electronic upgrades so far with no weapons upgrade announced so far.
    avatar
    GarryB

    Posts : 16149
    Points : 16780
    Join date : 2010-03-30
    Location : New Zealand

    Re: BMP-1/BMP-2 Upgrades and Variants

    Post  GarryB on Tue Apr 18, 2017 5:20 am

    If they decide to upgrade mass amounts of BMP-2's that would mean other vehicles are far more behind than planned otherwise there is zero reason to put money into such a project if things like the Kurg are just around the corner.

    No it would not.

    They are upgrading all in service equipment, it means nothing regarding the new replacement equipment in development.

    Looks like the "Berezhok" upgrade, not really wise to keep working on BMP-2s anymore since Kurganets is on the way, but still a good choice for exports to upgrade to, although BMP-3s would probly be a better investment for them.

    Upgrading the enormous existing fleet of vehicles makes rather more sense than saving money and spending it on the new vehicles to trickle into service in a year or twos time.

    It is a way to get existing forces used to more advanced and capable systems and also to get work for companies that will soon be producing new equipment for the new vehicles too.

    Also, these vehicles will be going into reserve soon and it is always wise to keep your reserve up to date as much as possible.

    They will go to reserve when there are enough new vehicles for operational use... which will take a few years to achieve.

    This logic makes sense if Russia already had all the Kurgs etc they wanted. If this was just to update some naval forces or back water reserve garrison units that use maybe a couple hundred BMP-2's that would be an understandable move. To upgrade thousands of them for domestic units doesn't.

    If there is an upgrade available for the fleet it makes sense to apply it when there is money available... it seems there is money available.

    Saving money for a vehicle not even in service yet and then to spend money on vehicles going into reserve is stupid.

    Spend the money now on in service vehicles. What works and what does not will show up in use and that can be applied to the new vehicles being developed.

    They don't they will not spend tons of money upgrading BMP-2's when they still have to buy tons of new vehicles to replace said BMP-2's.

    The BMP-1s will be replaced first... it will likely be 5-10 years before the BMP-2s are gone from frontline service... especially all its modifications and specialist versions.

    You get the best bang for your buck upgrading existing types already in service... not by saving your pennys for vehicles that are not in service yet.

    Export is another story but domestic? no way. Russian Mod would have to be pretty foolish to do this, not like they have unlimited money even my country who spends way more than them would have an issue with such a concept.

    Russian MOD does not upgrade their vehicles so they can be exported... that is not their function or their focus. If the Russian export company decides to export material it might offer upgrades but usually to seal the deal as a bonus. Ie free old vehicles and you pay for the upgrades to make them useful.

    So far ~400 were upgraded with another 580 in the second order for about ~1000. All mechanical and electronic upgrades so far with no weapons upgrade announced so far.

    So they have already upgraded half the vehicles they were planning to upgrade... there is no way they could have introduced 1,000 Kurganets vehicles to replace the BMP-2s in service for that sort of money in that sort of time... so it is money well spent.


    _________________
    “The West won the world not by the superiority of its ideas or values or religion […] but rather by its superiority in applying organized violence. Westerners often forget this fact; non-Westerners never do.”

    ― Samuel P. Huntington, The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order
    avatar
    0nillie0

    Posts : 56
    Points : 58
    Join date : 2016-05-15
    Age : 30
    Location : Flanders, Belgium

    Re: BMP-1/BMP-2 Upgrades and Variants

    Post  0nillie0 on Tue Apr 18, 2017 10:09 am

    GarryB wrote:
    So they have already upgraded half the vehicles they were planning to upgrade... there is no way they could have introduced 1,000 Kurganets vehicles to replace the BMP-2s in service for that sort of money in that sort of time... so it is money well spent.

    Well from what i know the electronic upgrades consist of the integration of a new intercom and R-168 radio stations. I don't really know what is being upgraded mechanically.

    Imho this is more of an essential "update" to ensure these vehicles remain capable of inter-operation with the land forces, rather than an upgrade of the overall vehicle capabilities. It is clearly a short term thing. If they where planning on keeping large amounts of BMP-2's in frontline service for the next 10 years or so, imho we would see far more extensive upgrades being implemented. Both the Russian MoD, and the enemies of Russia have stated and acknowledged that the BMP-2 is no longer viable for modern high intensity conflicts.

    Imho the Berezhok upgrade which was announced but not yet implemented, is the true mistake here. If they would have done this when the kit first became available, i would understand this. But with the development of the Kurganets and other new vehicle families so far advanced, it would make more sense to simply wait for that development to be completed. And as the new vehicles enter service, use the technology in these vehicles to slowly start upgrading the BMP-2's in parallel with simplified packages. For example, integrate the gunner sight, and simplified FCS of Kurganets IFV, and develop new side skirts that can carry the add-on armor modules. Or simply remove the existing BMP-2 turret and replace it with the RWS for the Kurganets altogether. I think the key feature is that they need to find a way to upgrade the protection of the BMP-2, while retaining its mobility and low profile.

    Al tough this would be initially more expensive, i think the benefit of having frontline forces and reserves/second line forces using similar systems would be greatly beneficial in the longer term.

    In the future, BMP-2's could even be converted to operate fully unmanned alongside the kurganets or armata family.

    Even tho i always hoped that Berezhok would be implemented, imho its too little too late now. And i hope that in the future we can see a BMP-2 with some features of Kurganets instead.
    avatar
    GarryB

    Posts : 16149
    Points : 16780
    Join date : 2010-03-30
    Location : New Zealand

    Re: BMP-1/BMP-2 Upgrades and Variants

    Post  GarryB on Tue Apr 18, 2017 11:18 am

    Why not apply the Berezhok upgrade?

    Modify it so that it contains components compatible with the new electronic and sensor suites being developed in the new vehicle family systems, but they cannot be completely transferred to the BMP series because they have unmanned turrets which none of the BMPs have.

    BMP-2s already have front mounted engines and rear mounted doors... so they are a step ahead of the BMP-3s in that regard.

    Fitting the Standard APS system should bulk up their armour protection and applique armour should further improve performance without increasing weight that much.

    You can't remove the turret and replace it with a RWS... where would the commander and gunner sit?

    Its main purpose is troop transport... let it continue to do that...

    Both the Russian MoD, and the enemies of Russia have stated and acknowledged that the BMP-2 is no longer viable for modern high intensity conflicts.

    With Kornets and RPG-28s about no western IFV is safe either...


    _________________
    “The West won the world not by the superiority of its ideas or values or religion […] but rather by its superiority in applying organized violence. Westerners often forget this fact; non-Westerners never do.”

    ― Samuel P. Huntington, The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order
    avatar
    0nillie0

    Posts : 56
    Points : 58
    Join date : 2016-05-15
    Age : 30
    Location : Flanders, Belgium

    Re: BMP-1/BMP-2 Upgrades and Variants

    Post  0nillie0 on Tue Apr 18, 2017 12:08 pm

    GarryB wrote:Why not apply the Berezhok upgrade?


    You can't remove the turret and replace it with a RWS... where would the commander and gunner sit?

    Its main purpose is troop transport... let it continue to do that...

    I agree on that. My personal opinion on the matter is that with the advances in computerized FCS and digital battlefield monitoring systems, a personnel carrier shouldn't require both a gunner and a commander. I think the commander can fulfill both roles from a single station, which would create additional space for a fully equipped dismount. As seen in the picture below, the BMP-2 can be converted for remote weapon station integration, while still maintaining a fairly large area available for dismounts. However, i do understand that there is a difference in doctrine and tradition between East and West, and that such as a drastic modification of the vehicle hull comes at a cost and may not be as efficient in practice.

    Inside of the BMP-2 upgraded by Excalibur Army : (note the commander and gunner stations at the front. The reconfigured hull reduces the transport capacity to just 6 fully equipped dismounts).



    With Kornets and RPG-28s about no western IFV is safe either...

    Yes this is true, and it is exactly the reason why Berezhok is so lethal. But this should not stop Russia from trying to improve the protection of its BMP-2 crews either. This can be done in a number of ways
    - Add active protection suite used in Kurganets/T-15
    - Add new addon armor used in Kurganets/T-15
    - Add addon armor kits already developed for previous iterations of the BMP-2M
    - Reconfigure the chassis so that there is no ammunition near the crew, and there are safer ways to exit the vehicle (replace the rear doors). IMHO is the main problem of the Berezhok upgrade. Ammo remains near crew, while side and rear armor remain equally vulnerable.  

    Or a combination of the above.

    Taking in to account doctrine and cost efficiency, the best way to go would probably be to add active protection in combination with increased firepower of the Berezhok. So in conclusion, i agree to that.
    But i also look at other possibilities.

    Edit*
    One other issue i have with Berezhok is the fixed grenade launcher. I rather wish they could integrate a commander sight similar to that on the T-14 and T-90MS, which is combined with a weapon station. Imho the grenade launcher is more efficient if it can operate independently from the turret. But this off course is wishful thinking.
    avatar
    VladimirSahin

    Posts : 414
    Points : 432
    Join date : 2013-11-29
    Age : 26
    Location : Florida

    Re: BMP-1/BMP-2 Upgrades and Variants

    Post  VladimirSahin on Wed Apr 19, 2017 2:34 am

    So the upgraded BMPs are the BMP-2M variant (berezhok turret)??
    avatar
    AlfaT8

    Posts : 1313
    Points : 1320
    Join date : 2013-02-02

    Re: BMP-1/BMP-2 Upgrades and Variants

    Post  AlfaT8 on Wed Apr 19, 2017 4:27 am

    GarryB wrote:
    Looks like the "Berezhok" upgrade, not really wise to keep working on BMP-2s anymore since Kurganets is on the way, but still a good choice for exports to upgrade to, although BMP-3s would probly be a better investment for them.

    Upgrading the enormous existing fleet of vehicles makes rather more sense than saving money and spending it on the new vehicles to trickle into service in a year or twos time.

    It is a way to get existing forces used to more advanced and capable systems and also to get work for companies that will soon be producing new equipment for the new vehicles too.

    Looks like i was dead wrong, that's not the Berezhok upgrade, not sure what 2M variant that is, Vanilla 2M+cage/side armor?? scratch

    Well if they can get them upgraded at a good pace, than sure.

    kopyo-21

    Posts : 63
    Points : 65
    Join date : 2013-08-21
    Location : Bangkok - Thailand

    Re: BMP-1/BMP-2 Upgrades and Variants

    Post  kopyo-21 on Wed Apr 19, 2017 6:03 am

    AlfaT8 wrote:
    GarryB wrote:
    Looks like the "Berezhok" upgrade, not really wise to keep working on BMP-2s anymore since Kurganets is on the way, but still a good choice for exports to upgrade to, although BMP-3s would probly be a better investment for them.

    Upgrading the enormous existing fleet of vehicles makes rather more sense than saving money and spending it on the new vehicles to trickle into service in a year or twos time.

    It is a way to get existing forces used to more advanced and capable systems and also to get work for companies that will soon be producing new equipment for the new vehicles too.

    Looks like i was dead wrong, that's not the Berezhok upgrade, not sure what 2M variant that is, Vanilla 2M+cage/side armor?? scratch

    Well if they can get them upgraded at a good pace, than sure.
    BMP-2M: three projects with the same name:

    1. Joined project with BMP-3 turret (100mm combined 30mm gun)
    2. Tula "Berezhok" upgrade with 30mm 2A42 gun, Ags-30 30mm grenade and Kornet laser beam riding ATGM
    3. Kurgansky "Brezhok" upgrade with embodiment, 30mm 2A42 gun and Ataka radio guided ATGM

    https://topwar.ru/21909-bmp-2m-tri-proekta-s-odnim-imenem.html


    Last edited by kopyo-21 on Thu Apr 20, 2017 12:38 am; edited 1 time in total
    avatar
    Book.

    Posts : 698
    Points : 761
    Join date : 2015-05-08
    Location : Oregon, USA

    Re: BMP-1/BMP-2 Upgrades and Variants

    Post  Book. on Wed Apr 19, 2017 6:41 am





    Ru do the Moderna. Berezhok
    http://bmpd.livejournal.com/2517253.html

    Sponsored content

    Re: BMP-1/BMP-2 Upgrades and Variants

    Post  Sponsored content


      Current date/time is Thu Jul 20, 2017 8:30 pm